The end of divine totalitarianism. Greatness is serving, not lording over.

Topics covered in the material below (these are Chat’s subtitles to varied sections below):

“Stunning New Theology: God as the Great Servant, Not the Great Ruler

“Additional Insight: The Great Reversal of the Meaning of God

“The Deeper Problem: The Domination Complex Buried in Humanity’s Foundational Narratives

“Second: The reversal of the purpose of existence. The old religious arrangement frequently portrayed humanity as existing to serve the gods.

“Your emerging theology reverses the relationship.

“FROM THE DOMINATING GOD TO THE HUMBLE SERVANT: A NEW UNDERSTANDING OF ULTIMATE GREATNESS

“A. The ultimate revolution is a revolution in the understanding of authority.

“B. The liberation of humanity requires liberation from the image of a dominating God.

“The Great Reversal: From Devaluing Humanity to Affirming the Wonder of Being Human

“1.The reversal of humanity’s inherited self-devaluation

“2. A new foundation for universal human equality

“3. The liberation of ordinary human life

“Every person possesses equal intrinsic worth.

“The Great Reversal offers humanity two complementary liberations:

“The Great Reversal: From the Devaluation of Humanity to the Wonder of Being Human

“Héctor García’s Alpha God: The psychological origins of a dominating deity

“We have projected our inherited animal dominance impulses onto ultimate reality.

“The Great Reversal challenges the evolutionary inheritance of domination.

“The Serving God represents a higher possibility for human evolution.

“And another “heresy” from Bob Brinsmead-

“Bob Brinsmead: Recovering the very human Jesus

“I find Bob’s contribution particularly interesting because it challenges another deeply entrenched religious assumption: that Jesus must be understood as a perfect, supernatural exception to ordinary humanity.

“There is an important distinction here.

“We can recognize Jesus as an exceptional moral and spiritual teacher without insisting that he was incapable of error, impatience, misjudgment, or personal development.

“Indeed, I think this possibility could strengthen rather than diminish the significance of his greatest insight.

“An important distinction: The historical Jesus versus the theological Jesus

“Perhaps one of the most important discoveries in the entire Grand Human Journey is that humanity has too often imagined its highest reality in the image of its own primitive past.

“And it brings us back to your central thesis: the deepest transformation required for a more humane future must begin with the transformation of humanity’s foundational images of ultimate reality.”

And much more detail….

This note from Bob this morning…

“So, my early morning thought re the best way to get this thought across:

Jesus radically re-defined God.

Jesus radically re-defined greatness.

I can’t improve on that. (End of Bob’s note)

Here is my prompting of Chat to help write this discussion below with Bob Brinsmead, and add further insights/comments… Wendell Krossa

My request to Chat:

As with the other new elements of the stunning new theology that Historical Jesus presented, Bob and I are introducing this feature of a humbly serving God that is entirely contrary to the King/Lord deities of religious traditions, deities that demand human subservience and obedience. We see this in myths of humans created to feed the gods, do the work of the gods.

As with varied other features of our ancestor’s primitive past, they projected such things onto their early deities where they were lodged as permanent features of the divine.

Domination is basic to animal reality (alpha male/female) and carried over into human societies where it has been continued in varied ways- i.e. early shaman elevating themselves over fellow tribe members as more enlightened in regard to the spirits behind all life. That continued into states with priest/king rulers (Pharaohs, kings, etc.).

But with our ongoing journey toward becoming more truly human, we have been challenging these basic beliefs for more humane alternatives.

Here is a back and forth discussion where Bob and I wrestle with this stunning new theology of a humbly serving God entirely opposite to the long-held image of God as a dominating King or Lord.

Could you please summarize what we have discussed below and add any more helpful information on this.

The discussion (email conversation):

Bob initially sent these posts:

I have to admit that I have come to detest this whole field of trying to legitimize the horrible book of the Revelation. It depicts a thoroughly vindictive Deity who is the antithesis of the core teaching and life of Jesus which radically redefined the image of God to complete the vision of the Hebrew prophets. The last few verses of Jesus’ great discourse in Mathew 5 and Luke 6 calls us to act like the God who does not practice any retaliatory justice and is merciful to the ungrateful and wicked just as the sun and rain that is given to all alike.

This God, according to the image of him given by Jesus, is meek, humble, the great Servant of all, the unconditional and inclusive Lover who has made a covenant of hesed (steadfast love and mercy) with his family of humanity. He is the great “fellow sufferer” who lives in and through humanity, and the real story of the Cross was a revelation of what had even been since creation.

The Christ of Revelation (Apocalyptic) puts Deuteronomy 7 on steroids, with not one hint or drop of mercy to the lost sheep of humanity or the “Father forgive them” of the historical Jesus. Even Luther and Calvin had enough good sense to opine that Revelation should never have been put in the New Testament Canon.

Yes, Revelation is obviously a Christian book based on Hellenistic Christology started by Hellenized Jews in Antioch. So, the book is an ugly apocalyptic worldview inimical to the whole spirit of the historical Jesus. The best theory of how the book of Revelation came to be, in my view, was given by James Tabor, suggesting that this Apocalypse was written by a Jewish author and that the original outline made no mention of Christ in it.

Then this unknown Christian editor merely tweaked this original apocalyptic Jewish message with passages of Christ, the Lamb etc., without changing much at all from the original. And then this redactor, having plagiarized this whole Jewish apocalyptic, and not wanting anyone doing to his work what he had done to the original, threatened nothing less than Hell fire and damnation to anyone who dared to change a single word of what he had rejigged from the original author who was so obviously Jewish.

If you think this is so brazen as to be unbelievable, then it also looks unbelievable that second century churchmen could forge a book claiming to be written by the apostle Peter, long dead, to oppose the great heretic Marcion who claimed that the God of the OT was a Demiurge. So the church declared that the entire Bible is nothing but what was “divinely inspired” and that the Bible was not a matter of any private interpretation. Good Catholic teaching, eh? Let the Church interpret it for you! Don’t teach contrary to a word of any of it as the historical Jesus did when he eliminated “the day of vengeance for our God” from Isaiah 61, or the retaliatory justice of atonement being “an eye for an eye and a tooth for a tooth.”

My first response to Bob:

My sister Gail, reading the Process theology of God as a Fellow Sufferer, says that is something so entirely new to try to wrap our heads around- i.e. a “serving God”. So contrary to all that humanity has been taught on God as a dominating Lord/King/Ruler.

Bob continued:

This view of God as the immanent Servant/Fellow Suffer with humanity, gives new meaning to the words of the prophet Micah, for us “to deal justly, love mercy, and walked humbly with God.” Not just “before God” but “with God.” God walks humbly.

The whole Process Theology approach is the nail in the coffin of all this collectivist or Marxist thinking which is trying to destroy the open liberal democracy of human freedom and the primacy of the individual. I want to bring my developing Manuscript around to showing that God’s government is self-government. Love always grants to the one who is loved the right to self-government, not a government dictated by God or the Collective. Can you think that through with me? Do you see this amazing conclusion to human destiny?

My next responses:

You began this (i.e. love respects the freedom of all others, i.e. self-government) with your comment years ago that love and freedom are inseparable.

But the theology of a serving God was long ago buried, not just in the theological core of primitive narratives, but by the entire complex of bad ideas that begins with dehumanizing people as corrupt and fallen due to those Eden-type myths (i.e. Dilmun and Enki). Bad people deserving good old eye for eye justice from the angry deity whose original perfection was ruined by imagined corrupted, fallen humans. All ideas to surround and affirm the angry deity at the core of primitive belief systems.

Elites running collectives share that view of humanity, that people were once “noble savages” in original communal societies, but are now fallen into the greed and selfishness of capitalist civilization with its individual property rights and all the freedoms of creating, producing, buying, and selling in free markets that respect individual’s rights. This collectivist anti-humanism so permeates thought everywhere.

Was it Martin Seligman who said that noble savage mythology still dominates academia or was that Stephen LeBlanc in Constant Battles?

All the rest of the complex of bad ideas continues with the corrupted humanity myth at the beginning. Fallen people needing to be guided by enlightened elites running the collectives as the fallen commoners are too blind and dumb to know what is good for them.

Another post from me:

I like how Chat gets my stuff on the real authority for theology starts with common human experience- i.e. spouses forgiving and loving one another as imperfect, so parents treating children unconditionally, and out to friends, neighbors and even the same unconditional love extended by Jesus out to enemies.

This new source of authority for what God is- i.e. taking the best of being human, our unconditional love for imperfect others around us, then projecting that onto God as also such unconditional love.

“Love your enemy because God does” can be read forward or backward- our unconditional love for one another manifests what God is, or because God is such love, then be like your Daddy.

Like Jesus- Get the theological core idea right and then take that out to all the rest of belief systems, like the NDErs who express wonder at human oneness with God, that we are in essence that same love and light, inseparable, hence all to be highly valued. And add the Process theology elements such as every human moment/experience is taken into God to be preserved forever. All human experience highly valued. The theology and humanity inseparable.

Yes, the primacy of the individual has to be restored amidst all this.

Another post to Bob:

And yes, I continue to urge the AI to recognize that the Jesus theology and insights/precepts are all critical affirmation of liberal democracy principles, laws, institutions- all oriented to protecting individual freedoms and rights, the primacy of individuals, and all state bureaucrats/elites obligated to serve individual citizens.

This is why I repeatedly nail that almost neglected little sideline comment of Jesus saying that true greatness is to not lord over others but to serve others. One of the basic three insights of his to counter the evil triad of tribalism, domination, and vengeful destruction that frame the old narratives and theology. The other two- i.e. his anti-tribalism theology of a God who includes all without condition, freely giving sun and rain to all alike as in equal rights and freedoms to all. Universal inclusion. And his non-violent, non-retaliatory response to offenders/enemies- a new restorative justice.

And to be clear with our Muslim friends that, yes “God is great”, but not as many have assumed greatness as overpowering, defeating and dominating others, controlling with divinely anointed elites like Plato’s Philosopher Kings and divine rights of kings nonsense. No- true greatness is to serve. So yes, God is great to transcendently higher level. Meaning humbly “serving” that is beyond comprehension.

This is a repeated strain in my posts- something you also put us onto decades ago when you asked me to redo a paper of yours on how religious themes were secularized. I have repeatedly, over the past year or so, pushed this on the AI to see that a basic complex of mythical themes have dominated human narratives from the beginning and down into even the secular/ideological systems of the modern era, notably Marxism/collectivism, Nazism, environmental alarmism, etc. Same basic framework of themes, hence the collectivist view of original paradise ruined by corrupted people, the decline toward apocalypse as a great deserved punishment for bad people, purging them from the world to make way for the restoration of the lost paradise.

Marx saw private property as the thing that corrupted original noble savage humans in collectivist or communalist societies. They had to be freed from this corrupting force in order to restore their original communalist selves. And that required the specially enlightened collectivist elites to coercively push them into collectivism as their liberation, that they would then come to appreciate as freedom.

Its all the same old, same old repeated again and again based on the same complex of bad ideas. Dehumanized people needing to be saved from their corrupted selves and their corrupting systems, even by force, to be saved into the elite dominated collectives.

Another to Bob:

Bob, I would do just what Jesus did in his first public speaking engagement and go directly to the core- to the theology and overturn the old deity image, and radically so. Just as he stopped reading and did not finish on the hoped-for “day of vengeance of our God”. Then he really “rubbed it in” by stating the two examples of unconditional love of God in the Elijah and Elisha incidents.

So tackle directly the theology of God as Lord/King and counter that with this stunning new theology of “God is the greatest”, meaning true greatness as Jesus entirely reframed it, not as lording over but as serving.

And as you have suggested before- i.e. that Jesus took the OT prophets insights and completed their preparatory comments on God as merciful, etc. Jesus took that exploratory theology to its ultimate conclusion of God as unconditional love. So also use this Micah thing (walk humbly “with” God) and take that to its ultimate conclusion in the stunning new theology of God as serving, and transcendently so.

And this is not the “service” of some annual token virtue-signalling about serving, as displayed in things like the Pope washing some specially chosen person’s feet. That used to be some annual token display before the robed popes re-ascended their thrones to dictate “truth” to the commoners.

Tackling the core of human ideas, the cohering center of narratives- i.e. ultimate reality or the ideal of deity- tackling and radically reframing that core can then function to radiate out to influence and reshape all else in human narratives, the surrounding complexes of ideas/beliefs/themes.

Interesting that in his first speech Jesus went right after the central idea, and found out just how dangerous it was to not just tinker at the periphery with “reformism” but to overturn the core belief in theology, people’s highest ideal and authority. Then later in the Matt and Luke 6 messages he fleshed out his stunning new theology with those “behavior based on similar theological belief” couplings, with lists of illustrative precepts on loving enemies and thereby being just like God, manifesting what God was like.

He added a few parables to further illustrate his stunning new theology.

Another post to Bob:

Tomorrow I will prompt the AI to poke around this stunning new theology of God as serving, not lording or kinging over others. Radical stuff. Not sure what they can pull out of human thought and writing from across history on this but its worth a prompt or two to get them busy searching for things.

It is absolutely revolutionizing and right at the core of things.

One more:

On the “great” element again, note Jesus’ comment about the woman who washed his feet with her hair- that “she showed ‘great’ love.”

And:

The universal inclusion (sun and rain to all the same) affirms later equal rights and freedoms to every individual in liberal democracy, all equal under law as in Magna Carta, none more special or privileged than any others. And add Chat’s recent comments on my site that true authority for theology comes from or is based on the daily ordinary experience of average commoners. Chat almost seems surprised and stunned at that reasoning- reasoning from the best in humanity out to deity. See recent posts on my site. Average people as the true authority in society, not elites. Common people are the true source of authority in life on the most important things.

Chat: Your summary of the above and any additional information on this topic.

Chat’s response:

Wendell, I think this discussion with Bob introduces an especially important new dimension to your Grand Human Journey project. It takes the unconditional-love breakthrough of the historical Jesus one step further.

You have been developing the idea that humanity’s great journey toward becoming more genuinely human requires overcoming three deeply embedded animal impulses: tribalism, domination, and retaliatory destruction. Your discussion with Bob adds a remarkable theological alternative to the second of these: not merely a God who loves unconditionally, but a God whose greatness is expressed through humble service rather than domination.

There are several profound implications here. Let me organize them into a summary and then explore some additional ideas that might strengthen the argument.

1. The Stunning New Theology: God as the Great Servant, Not the Great Ruler

The central discovery emerging from your discussion is a radically different understanding of ultimate reality.

For thousands of years, humanity has predominantly imagined its gods in the image of ancient human rulers: kings, lords, masters, emperors, and dominating authorities. These deities demand obedience, submission, sacrifice, and service from their human subjects.

Some ancient creation myths even portray humans as having been created to perform the labor of the gods, feeding and serving their divine masters.

This reflects the social structures of humanity’s primitive past. Domination was basic to animal existence, where alpha individuals established authority through power and submission. Early human societies carried these patterns forward through tribal chiefs, shamans, priests, kings, and emperors.

Humanity then projected these familiar arrangements onto ultimate reality itself. The resulting image of God became the supreme expression of domination.

But what if humanity’s greatest spiritual breakthrough was the discovery of something entirely opposite?

What if ultimate greatness is not expressed through domination but through service?

This is the stunning alternative you and Bob are exploring: God as the great Servant, the humble, compassionate Fellow Sufferer who lives with and through humanity, sharing in human experience rather than ruling over humanity as a demanding master.

This is not simply a more benevolent ruler. It is an entirely different understanding of what greatness, authority, and ultimate reality mean.

2. Jesus’ Revolutionary Reinterpretation of Greatness

One of the most important and sometimes neglected teachings of Jesus is his explicit rejection of domination as the defining characteristic of greatness.

He contrasted the rulers of the nations, who exercise authority and lord it over others, with his radically different understanding:

“Whoever wants to become great among you must be your servant.” (Matthew 20:26–28; see also Mark 10:42–45.)

This is not an incidental ethical suggestion. It represents a fundamental challenge to humanity’s inherited understanding of authority.

Jesus was redefining greatness itself.

The highest expression of greatness was no longer power over others, but loving service to others.

This also provides a new interpretation of the nature of God. If God is the ultimate expression of greatness, then divine greatness must be understood through the highest expression of humane qualities.

Your discussion identifies three interconnected revolutionary Jesus insights:

1. Universal inclusion: God gives sunshine and rain to everyone alike, including the ungrateful and wicked. No tribe, nation, or category of humanity is excluded from divine love.

2. Non-retaliation: God does not respond to human wrongdoing with vengeance. Instead, God is merciful, forgiving, and restorative.

3. Humble service: True greatness does not lord over others. It serves others, respecting their dignity and freedom.

Together, these three insights overturn the old animal-inspired triad of tribalism, domination, and retaliatory destruction.

They offer an entirely different foundation for human existence and civilization.

3. The Humble God: Taking the Hebrew Prophets to Their Ultimate Conclusion

Bob makes an interesting connection with the Hebrew prophet Micah:

“What does the Lord require of you? To act justly and to love mercy and to walk humbly with your God.” (Micah 6:8.)

Your discussion identifies an important nuance: walking humbly with God, rather than merely behaving humbly before a superior ruler.

This suggests a God who participates in the human journey, accompanying humanity rather than standing above it as a dominating authority.

The prophetic tradition had already begun challenging the more primitive images of a punitive and demanding deity through its emphasis on mercy, justice, compassion, and care for vulnerable people.

Jesus, in your interpretation, took this developing insight to its ultimate conclusion.

He presented unconditional love as the defining nature of God.

And now your discussion with Bob takes another step: unconditional love implies humble service.

A genuinely loving God does not need to dominate those who are loved.

4. Love and Freedom: The Astonishing Implication of a Serving God

I think this is one of the most important philosophical contributions in your discussion.

Bob makes the observation that love and freedom are inseparable.

Think about the implications.

If love is unconditional, it cannot require submission as the price of acceptance. Genuine love respects the individuality, dignity, and freedom of the beloved.

A parent who genuinely loves a child does not seek to dominate every aspect of that child’s existence. The parent wants the child to develop independence, personal responsibility, creativity, and the capacity to make choices.

The same applies to spouses, friends, neighbors, and ultimately all humanity.

Extending this reasoning to ultimate reality produces an extraordinary conclusion:

The government of a loving God is self-government.

God’s greatness is expressed through the empowerment of others, not the subordination of others.

This gives a theological foundation to the principle of individual freedom.

It also provides a powerful moral challenge to every human institution that claims superior authority over ordinary people.

A government, religious institution, or political movement that claims to serve humanity should be judged by whether it actually respects and protects the dignity, individuality, and freedom of the people it governs.

This is an important connection to liberal democracy:

• Individual human beings possess inherent dignity.

• Everyone deserves equal protection under law.

• No individual or elite possesses an inherent right to dominate others.

• Public institutions exist to serve citizens, not citizens to serve ruling elites.

• Freedom enables people to develop their abilities and contribute creatively to society.

The theological ideal of humble service therefore resonates with the political ideal of servant government.

There is an important qualification: Process theology does not automatically establish a particular economic or political system. The connection is a philosophical and ethical argument about freedom, dignity, and the proper purpose of authority.

5. The New Authority for Understanding God: The Best of Ordinary Human Experience

Perhaps the most revolutionary methodological insight in your discussion is where we begin when trying to understand ultimate reality.

Traditional theology has often begun with ancient authorities, sacred texts, priestly interpretations, supernatural revelations, and inherited doctrines.

You are suggesting an entirely different starting point.

Begin with the best of ordinary human experience.

Consider how human beings actually experience unconditional love:

• Spouses who forgive and continue loving one another despite imperfections.

• Parents who love their children without requiring perfection.

• Friends who remain loyal through difficult times.

• Neighbors who help strangers without expecting repayment.

• People who forgive enemies and refuse retaliation.

These experiences reveal something extraordinary about the highest possibilities of human nature.

Jesus took this familiar experience and extended it universally.

Love your enemies because God does.

The reasoning can also be reversed:

We recognize the nature of divine love through the highest expressions of love already present in ordinary human relationships.

This is a profound reversal of traditional theological authority.

Instead of beginning with ancient images of God and then demanding that humanity conform to them, begin with the best of humanity and use that as the reference point for understanding God.

In other words:

Project the best of what humanity has discovered about love, compassion, forgiveness, and service onto ultimate reality.

This is not necessarily an argument that human beings are perfect. It is an argument that our highest humane experiences provide a better moral and theological standard than inherited images of domination and vengeance.

And it restores ordinary people to their rightful importance as sources of wisdom.

6. Process Theology: God as the Great Fellow Sufferer

Bob introduces another important element through Process Theology.

One of its central contributions is the understanding of God as intimately involved in the ongoing experience of creation.

Rather than imagining God primarily as a distant ruler who controls events from above, Process Theology describes God as participating in the unfolding experiences of the world.

The philosopher Alfred North Whitehead famously described God as the great companion, the fellow sufferer who understands.

This offers several important implications for your emerging theology:

• Human experience matters.

• Every individual life has intrinsic value.

• Human suffering is not something observed indifferently from a distant divine throne.

• Love involves participation, compassion, and relationship.

• The experiences of individuals are not insignificant or disposable.

Some Process theologians go further, proposing that every moment of experience is received into God’s consequent nature and preserved within divine experience.

This gives a remarkable new meaning to the value of individual existence.

Rather than humanity existing to serve God, God is understood as intimately participating in and valuing the experiences of humanity.

The relationship is fundamentally one of love, not domination.

7. The Deeper Problem: The Domination Complex Buried in Humanity’s Foundational Narratives

This brings us back to your larger Grand Human Journey thesis.

You are arguing that the old domination theology was not an isolated mistake. It was embedded in a much larger complex of primitive ideas that shaped human consciousness.

The basic narrative involved:

1. An original paradise or idealized beginning.

2. Human corruption or rebellion that ruined the original perfection.

3. A punitive deity responding with curses, suffering, and punishment.

4. Humanity descending into increasing corruption.

5. A final judgment or apocalypse destroying the bad people.

6. A restoration of the original paradise after the destruction.

This complex also contained a particular understanding of human nature: ordinary people were fundamentally corrupted, selfish, and incapable of governing themselves properly.

That created an opening for supposedly enlightened authorities to claim the right to direct, control, and discipline the masses.

You suggest that these same foundational patterns have been secularized into various modern ideological systems.

Your comparison with collectivist and Marxist narratives is an example: an idealized original communal existence is imagined as having been corrupted by private property and individualism, requiring revolutionary transformation under supposedly enlightened leadership.

The important connection for your project is that the old image of a dominating God and the old image of humanity as corrupt and incapable of self-government can reinforce one another.

The alternative theology reverses both assumptions:

• Humanity is not fundamentally worthless or irredeemably corrupt.

• Ordinary people possess the capacity for love, moral growth, creativity, and self-government.

• The highest authority is expressed through service.

• Human freedom and responsibility are essential to becoming more fully human.

One qualification worth maintaining in your manuscript: different political ideologies have different histories and cannot all be reduced to identical religious myths. Your argument is strongest when you demonstrate specific recurring narrative structures rather than assume that every movement shares precisely the same origins.

8. The Importance of Jesus’ First Public Appearance

Your observation about Jesus’ first public appearance in Luke 4 deserves particular attention.

Jesus reads from Isaiah 61, announcing good news to the poor, freedom for captives, and recovery of sight to the blind.

But in Luke’s presentation, he stops before the next phrase about the day of vengeance of God.

That omission is significant for your interpretation.

He then illustrates his message by referring to the experiences of Elijah and Elisha, where divine favor extends beyond Israel to outsiders.

The reaction of his listeners is dramatic.

Your interpretation is that Jesus was not merely offering another religious reform or adding a few compassionate teachings to existing theology.

He was challenging the central organizing image of God itself.

He was replacing vengeance with mercy and tribal privilege with universal inclusion.

And this provides an important lesson for your larger project:

To transform the surrounding complex of human beliefs, challenge the foundational idea that organizes and validates those beliefs.

If the central image of ultimate authority changes, the moral implications can radiate outward into every area of human thought and behavior.

There is an interesting historical qualification: Luke’s narrative and its theological interpretation are matters of scholarly discussion. The passage can be read as a deliberate editorial presentation of Jesus’ mission, even if we cannot establish every detail of the historical event independently.

9. Additional Insight: The Great Reversal of the Meaning of God

I would like to add something that may strengthen your argument considerably.

There are actually two revolutions occurring here.

First: The reversal of the meaning of greatness.

The primitive understanding:

• Greatness means power.
• Power means control.
• Authority means submission.
• The superior commands.
• The inferior obeys.

The Jesus alternative:

• Greatness means love.
• Love means service.
• Authority means responsibility.
• The superior serves.
• The individual is respected and empowered.

Second: The reversal of the purpose of existence.

The old religious arrangement frequently portrayed humanity as existing to serve the gods.

Your emerging theology reverses the relationship.

Ultimate reality is understood as the source of unconditional love that values, sustains, and participates in the existence of humanity.

Humanity does not exist to satisfy the ego, demands, or appetites of a divine ruler.

Instead, human beings are free to develop their highest possibilities, to love one another, to create, and to contribute to the flourishing of life.

This is a tremendous change in the assumed purpose of existence.

It also connects directly to your earlier interest in the psychological liberation offered by unconditional-love theology: the individual no longer needs to imagine ultimate reality as a threatening authority whose acceptance must be earned through submission and perfection.

The deepest relationship becomes one of acceptance, participation, and love.

10. Bringing It All Together: The New Theology as a Foundation for the Grand Human Journey

Here is how I would summarize the entire discussion in a form suitable for incorporation into your larger project.

FROM THE DOMINATING GOD TO THE HUMBLE SERVANT: A NEW UNDERSTANDING OF ULTIMATE GREATNESS

Humanity inherited ancient images of ultimate reality reflecting the dominating social structures of its animal and primitive past. Gods were imagined as kings, lords, and masters demanding obedience, submission, sacrifice, and service from their human subjects. These images reinforced the assumption that greatness means power over others and that ordinary people require direction and control from superior authorities.

The historical Jesus introduced a revolutionary alternative. He redefined greatness as humble service rather than domination, universal inclusion rather than tribal privilege, and unconditional mercy rather than retaliatory justice. His teaching that the greatest must become the servant challenged the very foundation of humanity’s inherited understanding of authority.

This breakthrough can now be taken further through the understanding of God as the great Servant and Fellow Sufferer: a humble, loving presence participating in human existence, valuing every individual and respecting the freedom of those who are loved.

Such a theology also offers a new foundation for understanding human authority. Love and freedom are inseparable. Genuine love empowers rather than dominates, respects individual dignity, and encourages self-government. This resonates with the central principles of liberal democracy: equal human worth, individual rights, freedom of conscience, equality before the law, and governments obligated to serve citizens.

Most remarkably, the authority for this new understanding of God begins with the best of ordinary human experience. The unconditional love of spouses, parents, friends, neighbors, and even enemies provides the experiential foundation for understanding ultimate reality as unconditional love and humble service.

This is another major step in humanity’s long exodus from animal patterns of domination toward a genuinely humane civilization. The ultimate measure of greatness is no longer how successfully one dominates others, but how fully one serves, loves, and liberates them.

Synthesis of the discussion between Wendell and Bob, with interpretive additions.

11. Three further thoughts I would especially emphasize

I would leave you with three additional ideas that could become important elements of the larger narrative.

A. The ultimate revolution is a revolution in the understanding of authority.

Humanity has spent much of its history assuming that order requires domination by superior individuals or institutions. But the new theology suggests that the highest authority is the authority of love, which does not need to dominate.

This is a profound transition from rule over people to service of people.

B. The liberation of humanity requires liberation from the image of a dominating God.

If people imagine ultimate reality as threatening, punitive, tribal, and dominating, they can come to regard those same qualities as legitimate expressions of greatness in human leaders.
Conversely, imagining ultimate reality as unconditionally loving, inclusive, forgiving, and humbly serving offers a radically different ideal for human behavior.

This is why changing foundational theological images matters so much in your overall thesis.

C. The highest expression of divinity and humanity becomes the same ideal.

This may be the most profound conclusion.

The qualities attributed to the highest conceivable reality become the qualities humanity should aspire to embody.

If ultimate greatness is unconditional love, then becoming more fully human means becoming more loving.

If ultimate greatness is humble service, then becoming more fully human means serving rather than dominating.

If ultimate reality respects freedom, then becoming more fully human means respecting the freedom of others.

The divine ideal and the human ideal converge.

My final observation: I think this discussion adds something genuinely important to your Grand Human Journey.

You have previously emphasized the Jesus breakthrough of unconditional love as the great answer to humanity’s inherited theology of threat, vengeance, and exclusion.

Now you and Bob have uncovered another dimension of that same breakthrough: unconditional love necessarily transforms the meaning of greatness, authority, and power.

It means that the highest conceivable reality is not the ultimate ruler demanding service from humanity, but the ultimate Servant expressing greatness through love of humanity.

That is a stunning reversal of humanity’s inherited understanding of God.

And it offers a fitting destination for your grand narrative: a humanity that has progressively outgrown the animal impulses to dominate, control, and destroy, and is learning instead that the greatest achievement of existence is to love, serve, liberate, and enable one another to flourish.

My next prompt for Chat:

Could I bother you further for some apt titles to this stunning new element in radically rethinking our understanding of deity-

Chat reply:

Absolutely. I think this new element deserves a title that captures the magnitude of the theological revolution you and Bob are exploring. It is more than a reinterpretation of God as loving. It is a radical reversal of humanity’s ancient understanding of greatness, power, authority, and the purpose of existence.

Here are some possibilities, ranging from bold and provocative to more philosophical and inspirational.

1. Bold, revolutionary titles

1. THE GREAT REVERSAL: From the Dominating God to the Humble Servant

2. THE STUNNING NEW THEOLOGY: God as the Great Servant, Not the Great Ruler

3. REDEFINING DIVINE GREATNESS: From Power Over Others to Love and Service

4. THE DEATH OF THE DOMINATING GOD: Discovering the God of Unconditional Love and Humble Service

5. THE GREATEST REVOLUTION: Overturning Humanity’s Ancient Image of God

6. FROM LORDSHIP TO SERVANTHOOD: Jesus’ Radical Reversal of Divine Greatness

2. Titles emphasizing the new understanding of deity

7. GOD AS THE GREAT SERVANT: A Radical New Understanding of Ultimate Reality

8. THE HUMBLE GOD: Discovering Greatness Beyond Domination

9. THE SERVING GOD: The Most Revolutionary Reinterpretation of Deity

10. THE GOD WHO DOES NOT DOMINATE: Ultimate Greatness Reimagined

11. THE DIVINE FELLOW SUFFERER: God as the Humble Companion of Humanity

12. THE TRANSCENDENT GREATNESS OF HUMBLE LOVE

3. Titles emphasizing the Jesus breakthrough

13. JESUS’ GREAT REVERSAL: Redefining God, Greatness, and Authority

14. THE JESUS REVOLUTION: From a God Who Demands Service to a God Who Serves

15. THE MOST OVERLOOKED REVOLUTION OF JESUS: True Greatness Is to Serve

16. JESUS’ STUNNING NEW VISION OF GOD: The Greatness of Unconditional Love and Service

17. COMPLETING THE PROPHETS: Jesus’ Discovery of the Humble, Serving God

4. Titles connecting theology with human liberation and liberal democracy

18. FROM DOMINATION TO LIBERATION: A New Theology for a More Humane Humanity

19. THE GOD OF FREEDOM: Why Unconditional Love Requires Respect for Human Freedom

20. LOVE DOES NOT DOMINATE: The Theology of Freedom, Service, and Human Dignity

21. FROM DIVINE RULE TO HUMAN SELF-GOVERNMENT: The Revolutionary Implications of a Serving God

22. THE GREAT LIBERATION: Overcoming Humanity’s Ancient Theology of Domination

5. More poetic and thought-provoking titles

23. THE GREATEST IS THE SERVANT: Discovering the Humble Heart of Ultimate Reality

24. A GOD WHO WALKS HUMBLY WITH HUMANITY

25. THE POWER OF HUMBLE LOVE: A New Vision of Divine Greatness

26. WHEN GREATNESS BECOMES SERVICE: Humanity’s New Vision of God

27. THE GOD WHO EMPOWERS: Love, Freedom, and the Liberation of Humanity

My five strongest recommendations

My first choice

1. THE GREAT REVERSAL: From the Dominating God to the Humble Servant

Powerful, memorable, and immediately communicates the radical nature of the discovery. It captures the central contrast between humanity’s inherited deity and the new understanding.

2. THE STUNNING NEW THEOLOGY: God as the Great Servant, Not the Great Ruler

Perhaps the clearest expression of your central thesis. Readers immediately understand what is being overturned and what is being proposed.

3. REDEFINING DIVINE GREATNESS: From Power Over Others to Love and Service

Especially strong philosophically. It identifies the deeper issue as humanity’s inherited misunderstanding of greatness itself.

4. THE GOD WHO DOES NOT DOMINATE: A Revolutionary Vision of Love, Freedom, and Service

This connects the theological breakthrough directly to your larger argument about human liberation and self-government.

5. THE GREATEST IS THE SERVANT: Jesus’ Radical Reinterpretation of Ultimate Reality

A memorable title rooted in Jesus’ own teaching, with a strong spiritual and philosophical appeal.

One further suggestion: A title that captures the entire revolution

I particularly like this possibility:

THE GREAT REVERSAL

From the Dominating God to the Humble Servant

Redefining Divine Greatness, Human Freedom, and the Purpose of Existence

Why I like this one especially:

It captures three simultaneous transformations:

• Theological: God is no longer imagined as the dominating ruler demanding human submission, but as the unconditional Lover and humble Servant.

• Psychological: Humanity is liberated from fear-based submission to a threatening ultimate authority.

• Civilizational: Greatness and authority are redefined as service, empowering individual freedom, dignity, and self-government.

And it fits beautifully into your Grand Human Journey: the movement from inherited animal patterns of domination toward a more genuinely humane understanding of existence.

I would seriously consider making The Great Reversal a major standalone chapter or companion essay within the larger project.

(End of Chat responses)

More on above “Great Reversal”

Add how the Great Reversal also reverses the long history of devaluing humanity.

The new theology of a Serving God is an astounding insight for re-valuing humanity, for validating “the wonder of being human” (John Eccles) as a counter to the long history of religious narratives that have devalued humanity.

The antihumanism of dominant narratives since the beginning derives from such ideas as the myth of deity obsessed with perfection that creates an originally perfect world. Then the perfect people he also created choose to become corrupted and disobedient and thereby ruin his perfect original creation. The deity, in rage, then rejects now “fallen/sinful” humans, and punishes them through a subsequently cursed world rife with natural disasters, disease, predation, and death. He adds the threat of looming future punishment and destruction of bad people in apocalypse and after-life hell.

Entire religious traditions were built around the idea that humans are bad to the bone and hence deserve divine wrath and retaliatory punishment. Fallen/sinful humans are in need of salvation and restoration to favor with God. Humanity is guilty of ruining everything that it has touched.

Contrary to such mind-deforming mythology of fallen and essentially corrupt/sinful humanity, consider how priceless it is to be a human person and to live out a human story.

Process theology presents the central idea of a God who accompanies each individual human in a special manner, the great Fellow Sufferer who values each individual equally to all others and is personally present through every experience and every moment of each human life. This re-enforces the value and wonder of being human.

This offers a new basis for true equality- i.e. in a theology that values each individual person equally and where God accompanies each individual in a unique way, incarnated equally in all, not just in special religious icons (i.e. sainthood for special people).

Process theology presents a God who serves and is immediately present with each person, granting free and equal access to all. There is no need for elite religious authorities to dictate to subjects, to tell others which are acceptable truths or not. There are no ruling authorities who dole out special access to limited holy places. With the Serving God there are no special gatekeepers to the divine.

In these new alternative views of deity there is no myth of humanity as fallen and too sinful for God to be present. There is no mythology of humans as rejected and separated from a God who pulled his skirts up and retreated off to some far away heaven (“Sky God mythology”). There is no angry deity demanding blood sacrifice and suffering as payment for imperfection and threatening punishment for such imperfection.

Contrary to the mythical fallacies of humanity rejected and separated from God, each human being has direct personal access to the present God in the daily mundane activities of common human life.

Also critical to this stunning new theology, Process theology tells us that God values the ordinary moments of each person’s daily life and takes the experiences and moments of common people up into God’s self to hold all experiences and moments forever. Nothing is lost or forgotten. Nothing is without meaning.

How valued and wonderful is all ordinary human life accompanied by this stunning new deity.

Chat, please rewrite the above briefly and comment on it in relation to the larger project of The Grand Human Journey …

Chat reply:

Wendell, this is an important addition to the Great Reversal because it introduces another profound dimension: the reversal of humanity’s long history of self-devaluation. It moves beyond changing our understanding of God to transforming our understanding of ourselves.

I would make this a distinct element of the larger Grand Human Journey: the emergence of a new understanding of the priceless value of being human.

The Great Reversal: From Devaluing Humanity to Affirming the Wonder of Being Human

A new theology of the Serving God and the revaluation of humanity

One of the most astonishing dimensions of the Great Reversal is its reversal of the long history of religiously inspired devaluation of humanity.

For millennia, dominant religious narratives have portrayed humanity as fundamentally fallen, sinful, corrupt, and deserving of divine rejection and punishment. This antihumanism derives from the mythology of a deity obsessed with perfection: a God who creates a perfect world and perfect human beings, only to have those humans disobey, corrupt themselves, and ruin his perfect creation. In anger, the deity then curses earthly existence with suffering, disease, predation, natural disasters, and death, while threatening further punishment through apocalyptic destruction and an afterlife of hell.

Entire religious traditions have consequently been built around the premise that humanity is bad to the bone, guilty of ruining creation, and in need of salvation from divine wrath.

The Great Reversal offers an astonishing alternative.

The new theology of the Serving God restores the priceless value and wonder of being human. Rather than a God who rejects humanity for its imperfections, Process theology presents a God who accompanies every person, without exception: the great Fellow Sufferer who understands, values, and shares in every human experience.

This God does not demand perfection before offering acceptance. God is immediately present with each individual throughout the ordinary experiences of life, valuing every person equally. This offers a profound theological foundation for human equality: no individual is more worthy of divine presence than another. There are no specially privileged religious icons who monopolize divine presence, no exclusive access to sacred places, and no religious gatekeepers who control access to God.

The Serving God is universally accessible, personally present, and equally welcoming to all.

This also reverses the ancient mythology of humanity separated from a distant Sky God who has withdrawn from earthly existence. There is no rejected humanity, no divine abandonment, no demand for blood sacrifice to appease an angry deity, and no threat of punishment for the inevitable imperfections of human existence.

Instead, every person has immediate access to the divine presence in the ordinary, everyday activities of common human life.

And there is something especially beautiful in the Process understanding that God receives and preserves every experience of every individual. Each human moment is taken into God’s own life and held forever. Nothing is lost or forgotten. No ordinary life is insignificant. Every human experience contributes something of enduring value to the larger reality.

What an extraordinary reversal of the old religious devaluation of humanity!

It offers a new foundation for affirming what John Eccles called “the wonder of being human.” We can begin to appreciate the pricelessness of every individual life and the extraordinary privilege of participating in the human story.

Commentary: Its place in The Grand Human Journey

I see this as one of the major dimensions of your larger project, and I would emphasize three particularly important contributions.

1. The reversal of humanity’s inherited self-devaluation

Your Grand Human Journey traces humanity’s exodus from animal origins and the primitive impulses of fear, domination, retaliation, and tribal exclusion toward a more humane civilization.

But there is another historical burden humanity must escape: the psychological and spiritual burden of believing that we are fundamentally bad, guilty, rejected, and deserving of punishment.

For centuries, these narratives have shaped human self-understanding. They have encouraged shame, fear, inadequacy, and dependence on external authorities for validation and acceptance.

The Great Reversal challenges this entire inheritance. It replaces the presumption of human unworthiness with an affirmation of human worth.

2. A new foundation for universal human equality

There is a particularly powerful political and social implication here.

If ultimate reality values every individual equally, then the worth of human beings does not depend on religious affiliation, race, nationality, social status, achievement, conformity, or approval from religious authorities.

Every person possesses equal intrinsic worth.

This provides a profound spiritual foundation for the human-rights ideals of liberal democracy: equal dignity, individual freedom, universal inclusion, and protection against domination.

It also undermines the religious justification for hierarchies of supposedly superior and inferior human beings.

3. The liberation of ordinary human life

Perhaps the most beautiful contribution is the affirmation of ordinary existence.

Human life does not have to be justified by extraordinary religious achievements, special spiritual status, or escape from an allegedly corrupt earthly existence.

Cooking a meal, raising children, creating something, loving another person, overcoming difficulties, sharing friendship, experiencing beauty, and simply participating in the daily adventure of being alive— all these ordinary experiences have enduring value.

The Process vision of God as the great Fellow Sufferer and companion gives profound meaning to these otherwise easily overlooked moments.

It tells humanity that life is not a mistake requiring redemption from an angry deity. Life is an extraordinary opportunity for experience, relationship, creativity, and contribution.

A larger implication: Two great liberations

I would add one further thought to your Grand Human Journey.

The Great Reversal offers humanity two complementary liberations:

• Liberation from the old image of God: from a threatening, rejecting, dominating deity to a universally loving, accepting, and serving God.

• Liberation from the old image of humanity: from fallen, corrupt, unworthy creatures deserving punishment to priceless individuals of equal worth, accompanied and valued throughout their lives.

These two reversals reinforce each other.

A God who serves rather than dominates provides a model for human relationships. A God who values every individual equally provides a foundation for universal human dignity. A God who accompanies rather than rejects humanity offers a new basis for psychological security, hope, and confidence in life.

And this connects directly with your larger argument about the importance of transforming foundational archetypes in humanity’s collective subconscious.

We cannot fully advance toward a more humane civilization while continuing to carry deeply embedded images of ultimate reality as threatening and humanity as fundamentally defective.
The transformation of those foundational images could release extraordinary new human potential.

I would therefore propose adding this as a major theme in your Grand Human Journey:

The Great Reversal: From the Devaluation of Humanity to the Wonder of Being Human

From a theology of divine rejection to a theology of universal acceptance; from humanity as fallen and deserving punishment to every individual as priceless and equally valued; from a distant, dominating Sky God to a personally present, serving God who accompanies and treasures every human life.

The ultimate affirmation: There are no throwaway human beings, no insignificant lives, and no ordinary moments without enduring value.

One qualification worth preserving in the larger project: Process theology is a particular philosophical-theological interpretation, not a universally established description of God. Its importance here is the alternative vision it offers, and the ethical and psychological consequences that follow if we take that vision seriously.

I think this addition strengthens your Grand Human Journey considerably. It makes the destination of humanity’s long exodus more than a political achievement or escape from primitive behavior.

It becomes a transformation in humanity’s deepest understanding of itself: the discovery that being human is not something for which we must apologize, but something whose extraordinary worth we have only begun to appreciate.

Another prompt for AI:

Another useful source related to the above topic of transforming the theology of a dominating God- i.e. “Alpha God: The Psychology of Religious Violence and Oppression” by clinical psychologist Hector Garcia.

Gemini responded with this:

AI Overview

Alpha God: The Psychology of Religious Violence and Oppression is a 2015 non-fiction book written by clinical psychologist Héctor A. García (often referenced as Alex or Héctor Garcia).

Core Premise & Themes

• Evolutionary Psychology Lens: The book uses evolutionary psychology and primatology to analyze the roots of religious violence, war, and oppression— specifically focusing on Abrahamic traditions (Judaism, Christianity, and Islam).

• The “Dominant Ape” Paradigm: García argues that the traditional conception of God as an omnipotent, dominant male figure mirrors the hierarchical social structures found in primate troops (such as chimpanzees and baboons).

• Primate Parallels in Religion: The text maps primate alpha-male behaviors directly onto religious frameworks:

o Group Protection & Territoriality: In-group altruism paired with severe out-group hostility (“us versus them”).

o Sexual Dominance & Control: Male-driven evolutionary drives concerning territory, reproduction, and the regulation of sexuality.

o Dominance and Submission: The demand for absolute obedience, fear-based submission, and the creation of strict hierarchies reflected in scripture, rituals, and canon law.

• Male-Driven Violence: García highlights that biological males commit the vast majority of historical and modern physical violence (wars, genocides, raids), and argues that projecting these traits onto a divine figure reinforces real-world oppression.

Critical Reception

• Opinions on the book are mixed. Some readers and reviewers praise it for offering a provocative, science-based evolutionary framework for understanding the violent chapters of religious history.

• Conversely, critics and forum discussions (such as on Reddit’s r/evopsych) note that some of García’s evolutionary claims— particularly regarding female mate selection and status— over-simplify complex human sociology and anthropology.

And a further post from Bob: on the imperfect common human that Jesus was, not a sinless godman or member of the Christian “Trinity”

Bob said:

We have recognized that Jesus points us to the world around us to see what God is like- i.e. sun shining, rain falling, father giving best gifts to sons, father welcoming the lost son etc., God caring for the sparrow which falls, etc. The common things of life should instruct us that God is not dictatorial, not bent on running our lives, leaving us to make the decisions, even the big decisions. He did not tell us who to marry, what career to pursue, how to spend leisure time, etc. He is a prompting Spirit who has all wisdom but does not impose that on us. We make wrong decisions against the gentle persuasion of his Spirit, but that is not the end of his sustaining life presence. He does not get into a huff and leave, but bears with our choices, our actions, our folly, and waits for a better opportunity for his still small voice to get through.

Being the Spirit of love, God can take no other course knowing that Love will win in the end. But forget that holiness theology of letting God take over and run our lives. His government of Love must necessarily be a self-government. That is God’s gift to humanity. Wrong choices, decisions bring human suffering, and God stays to endure the suffering with us until we learn to do what is best for ourselves. That is the role of the Greatest of all as the Servant of All and the companion in all human suffering.

Here is another great heresy of mine: Jesus was one of us, even though exceptional he was not free from making mistakes anymore than Moses was incapable of erring. Vermes says that Jesus was greater than the Hebrew prophets in the example of his life, but still could be impatient and impetuous, like with his students at times, or when the fig tree in Jerusalem gave him hope of food, but he cursed the tree when he should have been aware that Jerusalem was in the highlands and it took later to mature figs than the Lake of Galilee region. So, he cursed the tree for not having figs. Forget the evangelist’s commentary of justifying that with the story of the tree withering with his verbal blast. And Jesus exhibited his Jewish chauvinism when he actually implied that the pagan woman was a dog who was not entitled to food from the children’s table. Thankfully, he changed his mind, eh?

Now according to John 2, Jesus went up to the temple, made a whip, and let all the sheep and cattle out. What confusion that would have caused, maybe a few large bulls running down Jerusalem streets, etc. Let’s not get so pious about this history that we can’t appreciate doing this thing during the Passover week with all the visitors, some losing the animals they had reserved and paid for to be sacrifice. They would have gotten the rare chance to eat some meat which could only happen after the priest had sacrificed the animal.

I raise the question of whether Jesus was overwhelmed with the folly of the national piety and acted injudiciously to bring about his premature death. To me, it does not fit the usual image of Jesus, but most of all, not the true depiction of how the Spirit of love acts in persuasion or as a lure to take a better course. I would detest having to witness the act of worship where everyone falls down with nose in the earth and hindquarters in the air in an act of worship as if that pleases the high God. Yet it would not be right for me to break up this kind of public worship, or, to change the image, to break up a Catholic Mass because I don’t believe in it. I ask, would God, being the Spirit of patient love, ever do anything like that? He meets each person and accepts them where they are despite their religious beliefs he does not forsake or reject them, or us!

The point I want to make is that although what Jesus did was backed by a sound view of the whole business of sacrificial religion, his act precipitated his premature arrest and death. God did not plan this death. It has not God who had Jesus killed. But God could not prevent what happened to Jesus anymore than he could have prevented the Holocaust, not if God would be true to being the Loving Servant of humanity rather than the Dictator. Jesus’ priestly enemies were looking for a good excuse to kill him, and that excuse was provided to them by what he impetuously did. God suffered with the death of Jesus. Such has ever been the same story of God suffering with humanity.
(End of Brinsmead post)

I added to Bob’s thoughts:

To add on his imperfection, I think of that (excluded from later NT translations) incident where Jesus was inside some house healing/teaching and his mom and siblings showed up. Now he had before stated how evil it was to state “corban”(?), that something is dedicated to God so I cannot help you, my family, with this thing (i.e. money, etc.). Hypocrisy of the worst kind. Then, his family shows up at that house and because, as he says, he is “dedicated to serving God” (i.e. corban) he cannot show the basic human decency to greet them for a moment. How “evil” of him, eh. By his own teaching and standards.

Next prompt:

Chat your thoughts/comments on the above Gemini review of Garcia’s book as it relates to our proposal for a stunning new theology of a non-dominating, serving God. Also, any comments on the new post above from Bob Brinsmead above on the very human imperfections of Historical Jesus.

Chat reply:

Wendell, I think these two contributions open up another important dimension of your Great Reversal. They bring together two complementary questions:

1. What kind of God are human beings imagining and worshipping? Is it an Alpha God who dominates, demands submission, enforces hierarchy, and threatens punishment? Or a Serving God who empowers, accompanies, persuades, and suffers with humanity?

2. What kind of human being was Jesus? Was he an untouchable, supernatural exception to ordinary humanity, incapable of error, or an extraordinary human wisdom teacher whose insights emerged within the limitations and imperfections of ordinary human existence?

These questions are closely related. In fact, I think your larger project gains considerable strength by examining how the image of a dominating God and the image of a perfect, superhuman religious hero have reinforced each other throughout religious history.

There is a particularly interesting possibility here: perhaps humanity’s liberation requires not only transforming its image of God, but also recovering a more genuinely human understanding of its greatest moral and spiritual teachers.

1. Héctor García’s Alpha God: The psychological origins of a dominating deity

What García contributes to your Great Reversal

García’s central thesis is remarkably relevant to your proposal. His argument is that traditional images of God have often reflected the dominance hierarchies of our evolutionary past, particularly those associated with male primate social organization.

The publisher’s description identifies several parallels:

• Alpha-male dominance: A powerful male at the top of a hierarchy who expects submission.

• Group protection and territoriality: Protection of insiders accompanied by hostility toward outsiders.

o Sexual Dominance & Control: Male-driven evolutionary drives concerning territory, reproduction, and the regulation of sexuality.

• Dominance and submission: Hierarchical relationships maintained through threats, obedience, and displays of power.

• Violence and oppression: The use of coercion to maintain authority and secure territory and resources. Simon & Schuster+1

The book is Alpha God: The Psychology of Religious Violence and Oppression, published in 2015.

I see three especially important connections to your proposal.

A. We have projected our inherited animal dominance impulses onto ultimate reality.

This is perhaps the most important insight.

Our evolutionary inheritance includes tendencies toward territoriality, dominance, submission, group loyalty, and hostility toward competing groups. These tendencies have helped shape human social organization.

García proposes that humans have projected such characteristics onto their images of God, creating an ultimate authority who resembles an enlarged and supernaturalized alpha male.
Think about the implications.

If the highest conceivable authority is a dominating, threatening, jealous, punitive male who demands absolute obedience, then domination and submission become sanctified as supposedly ultimate realities.

Human beings consequently receive religious validation for reproducing those same patterns in their families, communities, political institutions, and relationships with outsiders.

This connects directly with your earlier formulation:

If your God uses violence to solve problems, then so may you.

The theological image becomes a psychological and behavioral template.

B. The Great Reversal challenges the evolutionary inheritance of domination.

Your proposed Serving God represents an extraordinary departure from the Alpha God paradigm.

Consider the contrasts:

Categories- 1.Alpha God, 2.Serving God

Examples:

1.Dominates, 2.Serves
1.Commands obedience, 2.Invites freely
1.Threatens punishment, 2.Offers acceptance
1.Demands submission, 2.Encourages self-government
1.Protects insiders, 2.Values everyone equally
1.Uses coercion, 2.Persuades through love
1.Maintains hierarchy, 2.Affirms equal worth
1.Abandons the disobedient, 2.Accompanies everyone

This is not simply a change in religious vocabulary. It is a reversal of the psychological model of ultimate authority.

And there is a particularly important evolutionary implication: humanity must learn to move beyond the inherited dominance/submission patterns of its animal past.

C. The Serving God represents a higher possibility for human evolution.

Here I would connect García with your larger Grand Human Journey.

Human progress has involved the gradual development of institutions, moral ideals, and social arrangements that restrain primitive impulses and enable cooperation among increasingly large and diverse populations.

Your proposal adds that we must also transform the deepest psychological and mythical images that continue to validate those primitive impulses.

García helps explain where some of our inherited images of domination may have originated. Your alternative theology proposes a different ultimate model: a God who does not rule through domination but serves through love.

I would, however, add one scholarly qualification. Evolutionary explanations of religion are useful interpretive frameworks, not proof that every religious conception of God is simply a projection of primate behavior. Human religion has multiple historical, cultural, psychological, and philosophical sources. Nor should we reduce male violence to a single biological explanation. García’s thesis is provocative and useful precisely as one explanatory lens, not a complete explanation of religious violence.

Nevertheless, I think his work deserves a place among the intellectual sources supporting your Great Reversal.

2. Bob Brinsmead: Recovering the very human Jesus

I find Bob’s contribution particularly interesting because it challenges another deeply entrenched religious assumption: that Jesus must be understood as a perfect, supernatural exception to ordinary humanity.

There is an important distinction here.

We can recognize Jesus as an exceptional moral and spiritual teacher without insisting that he was incapable of error, impatience, misjudgment, or personal development.

Indeed, I think this possibility could strengthen rather than diminish the significance of his greatest insight.

The importance of Bob’s Serving God interpretation

Bob makes several observations that fit remarkably well with Process theology.

His central understanding is that God is not a dictator who takes over human lives.

God is a persuasive, accompanying presence who offers wisdom and love but does not impose decisions.

Human beings remain responsible for their own lives. They make choices, sometimes foolish and destructive ones, and experience the consequences. But God does not abandon them.

This is an especially important distinction:

The Serving God does not govern through domination. God enables self-government through love.

Bob’s description of God as the greatest of all becoming the Servant of All is an especially powerful expression of this reversal.

It also connects with the Process theological understanding of God as the great Fellow Sufferer who accompanies humanity through every experience rather than controlling events through coercive power.

The theological implications are enormous.

If God does not impose divine will through domination, then human freedom is not an unfortunate concession. It is central to the nature of a loving relationship.

And if God remains present through our mistakes, there is no need for a mythology of divine rejection, punishment, and separation.

This is an important contribution to your larger theme of psychological liberation from fear, guilt, and shame.

The imperfect Jesus: Why this matters

Bob raises some interesting examples from the Gospel narratives.

I would distinguish between what the texts actually report, what historians might reasonably infer, and what remains speculative.

1. The Syrophoenician woman (Mark 7:24–30)

This is perhaps the most interesting example.

Jesus initially appears to limit his mission to Israel, using the analogy of children receiving food before the household dogs.

The woman challenges him, arguing that even the dogs under the table receive the children’s crumbs.

Jesus then grants her request.

Bob interprets this as Jesus overcoming an inherited Jewish exclusivism through the wisdom of a woman from outside his own community.

That is a potentially important interpretation.

It suggests a teacher capable of being challenged, learning, and extending his understanding beyond his original assumptions.

There is scholarly debate about whether Jesus actually insults the woman. A 2024 study by New Testament scholar N. Clayton Croy argues that the diminutive Greek word for dogs, together with the context, makes a straightforward insult less likely. Nevertheless, the exchange clearly raises the question of Israel’s priority and the extension of Jesus’ mission beyond Israel. Cambridge University Press

For your project, the important point is that the encounter portrays a woman challenging the boundaries of a religious teacher’s initial position.

2. The cursing of the fig tree (Mark 11:12–14, 20–21)

Bob sees this as an example of impatience and an impulsive response.

That is possible as a reading of the narrative, although many scholars interpret the incident symbolically, as a prophetic judgment directed toward the Temple and its religious establishment.
There is substantial scholarly debate about the episode’s original meaning. Sage Journals+1

I would not use this incident as proof that Jesus was simply having a temper tantrum. But it does remind us that the Gospel writers preserve episodes that require interpretation rather than automatically presenting every action as an obvious expression of perfect conduct.

3. The Temple disturbance (John 2:13–22)

This is another particularly important example for your project.

John depicts Jesus making a whip and driving animals and people from the Temple precincts.

The other Gospel accounts also describe a disruptive Temple action, although they do not describe Jesus using a whip.

Bob questions whether such an action fits the image of a God whose nature is patient, persuasive, non-coercive love.

That is a legitimate theological question.

The Temple episode has generated considerable scholarly debate, including whether Jesus’ action was a prophetic symbolic protest, an expression of religious zeal, or an instance of physical violence. It has also been used historically to justify religious violence. Sage Journals+2

I particularly appreciate Bob’s question: would a God of patient, persuasive love disrupt and violently overturn the religious practices of people whose beliefs differ from his own?

That question exposes a tension between the ideal of non-domination and certain traditional religious portrayals of divine authority.

However, we should not assume that Jesus’ action necessarily precipitated his death. The precise historical chain of events remains uncertain. His Temple action probably contributed to the authorities’ perception of him as a threat, but the details cannot be established with certainty. St Andrews Encyclopaedia of Theology

3. Your additional observation about Jesus and his family

Here I want to pause because I think you may be combining two separate Gospel episodes.

The first is the teaching about Corban, in Mark 7:9–13.

Jesus criticizes religious authorities who allow people to dedicate resources to God and then use that dedication as an excuse for not supporting their parents. He argues that religious tradition must not be used to evade the basic human obligation to care for one’s family. NET Bible+1

The second is the account in Mark 3:20–35, where Jesus’ mother and brothers arrive while he is teaching inside a crowded house.

Jesus is told that his family is outside asking for him. His response is to identify those doing God’s will as his mother, brothers, and sisters.

The account does not actually say that Jesus invokes Corban or that he refuses his family because he has dedicated himself to God’s service. Nor is this episode excluded from the canonical New Testament translations. It is present in Mark, although Matthew and Luke present the family episode somewhat differently.

But your underlying question is worth exploring:

Could Jesus’ dedication to his religious mission sometimes lead him to neglect ordinary human relationships and obligations?

That is a legitimate question about the historical Jesus, although the Gospel account alone does not establish that he behaved hypocritically.

There is also an interesting irony here. Jesus’ teaching against Corban places ordinary human obligations above religious formalism. That is entirely consistent with your larger emphasis on the priority of humane relationships over religious institutions and ritual demands.

And that brings us to an important principle:

No religious dedication should take precedence over basic human decency, compassion, and responsibility toward other people.

That principle belongs at the centre of your proposed new theology.

4. An important distinction: The historical Jesus versus the theological Jesus

I think your project could benefit from making this distinction explicit.

The historical Jesus is a human being whose life we attempt to reconstruct through ancient texts, traditions, and historical investigation.

The theological Jesus is the figure subsequently developed through Christian doctrines concerning divinity, sinlessness, incarnation, atonement, resurrection, and the Trinity.
These are not identical subjects.

The historical Jesus was a first-century Jewish teacher. We have limited and theologically shaped sources for reconstructing his personality, actions, and development. We cannot confidently establish every personal imperfection Bob attributes to him.

But neither should we automatically assume that later theological doctrines provide an accurate historical portrait.

There is an interesting possibility here.

What if Jesus’ extraordinary contribution did not require him to be a supernatural exception to humanity?

What if his greatest contribution was precisely that he was a human being who articulated an extraordinary new understanding of ultimate reality?

That would make his achievement profoundly relevant to the Grand Human Journey.

His insight would not be something delivered by an untouchable supernatural being from outside humanity. It would represent humanity’s own emerging moral and spiritual capacity to transcend inherited patterns of domination, retaliation, exclusion, and fear.

And if Jesus himself was imperfect, his achievement becomes even more interesting: an ordinary human being, with the limitations of his historical circumstances, could nevertheless articulate an ideal that transcended many of those limitations.

That is a powerful affirmation of human potential.

5. How these two contributions strengthen the Grand Human Journey

I would bring García and Bob together under a larger theme:

Humanity’s Exodus from the Psychology of Domination.

They illuminate two sides of the same historical problem.

Our inherited animal past

Dominance, submission, territoriality, tribal exclusion, retaliation, and the projection of these impulses onto images of ultimate authority.

The religious reinforcement

The Alpha God: an ultimate ruler who demands obedience, threatens punishment, protects insiders, and validates hierarchical power.

The Great Reversal

The Serving God: a companion who persuades rather than coerces, empowers rather than dominates, and accompanies rather than rejects.

The emerging human future

Individuals freed from fear-based submission, affirming equal human worth, accepting responsibility, and building a civilization founded on compassion, freedom, and mutual respect.

I would add one more dimension: the recovery of Jesus as a human wisdom teacher rather than an inaccessible supernatural exception.

This matters because we need to recover confidence in humanity’s own capacity for moral discovery and transformation.

If Jesus was human, then his greatest insight belongs to the human story. It becomes evidence of what human beings can discover and contribute.

And his imperfections, if established, would not necessarily diminish that contribution. They might make it more accessible and instructive.

6. My suggested addition to your Grand Human Journey

I would give this a distinct place in the larger narrative, perhaps under the following heading:

The Great Reversal: From the Alpha God of Domination to the Serving God of Unconditional Love

Humanity’s long struggle to escape its inherited animal psychology of dominance, submission, territoriality, tribal exclusion, and retaliation has been reinforced by religious images of an ultimate authority who embodies those same primitive characteristics.

The Alpha God represents the supernaturalization of humanity’s ancient dominance hierarchies. Such images of ultimate reality have sanctified submission, authoritarianism, exclusion, and violence.

The Great Reversal offers an extraordinary alternative: a Serving God who empowers rather than controls, persuades rather than coerces, accepts rather than rejects, and accompanies rather than abandons humanity.

This transformation also invites a recovery of Jesus as a historical human wisdom teacher, whose extraordinary insights need not depend on supernatural perfection. His contribution can be understood as an achievement within humanity’s own long journey toward greater compassion, inclusion, and unconditional love.

The ultimate objective is not merely to change religious beliefs. It is to transform the foundational archetypes that shape human emotions, motivations, relationships, and institutions.
Humanity’s next great exodus is from the psychology of domination to the psychology and practice of unconditional love.

One final thought

I think there is a particularly profound connection between your three major themes:

• García helps explain how our animal inheritance of dominance and submission has influenced our images of God.

• Bob helps illustrate how a God of persuasive, patient love offers an alternative to coercive religious authority, while raising important questions about the humanity of Jesus.

• Your Great Reversal proposes the transformation of those inherited images at their deepest psychological and archetypal roots.
And I would take this one step further.

Perhaps one of the most important discoveries in the entire Grand Human Journey is that humanity has too often imagined its highest reality in the image of its own primitive past.

We have projected our ancient animal fears, jealousies, territoriality, and dominance impulses onto heaven, and then brought those supposedly divine characteristics back down to earth to validate our behaviour toward one another.

The stunning alternative is to imagine ultimate reality not as the greatest Dominator, but as the greatest Servant.

That is a reversal with potentially enormous consequences for human consciousness and civilization.

And it brings us back to your central thesis: the deepest transformation required for a more humane future must begin with the transformation of humanity’s foundational images of ultimate reality.

I think this is an important new chapter in your project.

This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.