The decline and fall of the west by the “Red/Green” alliance? Not so fast, eh.

Ongoing project here… Keep hope alive but recognize that “defeating the idea” that is trying to destroy western liberal democracy will involve the radical transformation of narratives, both religious and “secular/ideological”

See below Grok’s material on the “Red/Green” alliance to take down liberal democracies through “entryism”. Grok’s explanation- “Entryism is the tactic of infiltrating existing organizations, institutions, or movements from within in order to influence, redirect, or ultimately control them, rather than confronting them openly.”

Moving along…

Saad’s comments stirred me to another quote of Lennon’s “I read the news today, oh boy…”

I just saw an Instagram (Nov 5) from Gad Saad and others bemoaning the results of the US election as signaling the potentially ruinous shift away from the basics of liberal democracy and turning toward the inevitable destructiveness of collectivist/socialist alternatives. We see this across western liberal democracies in Europe- the notable shift by governing leftist elites toward more totalitarian collectivist and theocratic alternatives (i.e. the creeping totalitarianism of governing leftist elites censoring, silencing, even criminalizing of dissenters and political opponents- e.g. Germany, Britain, etc.).

Note also the further comments below on the “Red/Green” alliance and their shared commitment to infiltrate, undermine, and eventually destroy western liberal democracies. I posted previously the National Post article that illustrates this infiltration in Canada, in the section titled:

“Take the theological driver of bad behavior seriously. We have the better alternative.”

Posted on November 3, 2026 by Wendell Krossa

The article:

“The Muslim Brotherhood is a ‘cancer’ at the heart of Canada: Mohamed Fahmy is sounding the alarm and we should listen”, Michael Higgins, Nov 3

“Mohamed Fahmy’s Canada Act Now campaign is a warning about the Muslim Brotherhood infiltration of this country.”

https://nationalpost.com/opinion/the-muslim-brotherhood-is-a-cancer-at-the-heart-of-canada/

See also below, Grok’s fuller response on this. Here are a few quotes from that under the subtitle:

“Application of the Framework to Contemporary Threats Against Liberal Democracy

“The material summarized earlier identifies a persistent mythic complex whose cohering center is a tribal, dominating, and punitively destroying image of Ultimate Reality (or its secular equivalent Ideal). This complex sacralizes the “evil triad” of tribal dualism, domination, and punitive destruction of differing others. It externalizes the real inner struggle against those impulses, frames outsiders as irredeemable existential threats, and repeatedly licenses “salvation through destruction.” Liberal democracy, by contrast, institutionalizes the non-tribal, non-retaliatory, internal-restraint, and gradual-improvement alternative: equal rules, due process, limited power, protected dissent, and peaceful transfers rather than purging…

“Resurging Collectivism and Dualistic Crusades…

The “Red/Green” Alliance

“A related pattern is the temporary tactical cooperation between certain collectivist or revolutionary left currents (“red”) and Islamist theocratic movements (“green”), often sponsored or inspired by leading theocrats in Iran and similar actors. Despite fundamental differences— secular materialist millenarianism versus religious apocalyptic dualism— both share the goal of weakening or destroying liberal democratic orders. Both operate with dualistic framing (chosen/pure versus irredeemable enemies), demand for purification or revolutionary rupture, and readiness to treat existing societies as legitimate targets of destruction…”

(End of sample quotes)

Grok also explains the Red/Green alliance as it operates in the US to also overthrow that particular liberal democracy.

Further, note that contemporary woke progressivism with DEI is one front in the overall collectivist crusade. This particular variant has infiltrated all throughout Western educational systems and has been successfully indoctrinating new generations of students just as the Chinese and Russians stated decades ago that they would do- i.e. engage a long march through western institutions.

Others warned of the renewed alliances of collectivists with theocrats as in 1979 Iran where the temporary cooperation of leftists with theocrats, to serve as their “useful idiots”, resulted in their extermination following the success of that revolution.

Many of us prefer to assume that most people have progressed far enough toward understanding the common sense of liberal democracy as the best approach to organizing human societies to the point that we are now safe from further large-scale retreats to embrace totalitarian collectivism or theocracy. We see the amazing outcomes of protecting individual freedoms and rights from the centralizing of power and control under state elites and bureaucrats. We get Frederik Hayek’s insights on how distributed power among competitive individuals and state institutions (checks and balances) functions better to restrain the domination impulse in state officials and others.

We get the evidence from economists like Milton Freidman on the benefits of individual freedom as contrasted with the undermining of individual rights and freedoms under collectivist centralizing where individual are subjected to more state intervention and control always presented as “for the greater good, for the common good”, good as defined by collectivist elites after the manner of Plato’s “Philosopher Kings” the specially enlightened superiors who believe they alone know what is good for ignorant commoners.

With ongoing choice for the election of new collectivists who are emerging and promising lots of free stuff, the question arises of how many citizens are fully informed with the evidence of the historical outcomes of all forms of collectivism- i.e. the 24 failed experiments that have ruined entire societies. And where, in contrast, liberal democracy free market freedoms and individual rights have lifted billions out of poverty and this approach continues to lift all civilization and life toward a better future.

“Defeating the idea” that drives these totalitarian crusades that ruin societies:

In much of the public discussion of what is driving the societal-level shifts toward contemporary collectivism across western liberal democracies focus is given to differing positions (i.e. “Left/Right”, “Progressive/Conservative”) on a wide range of social/political/economic policies, etc.

But there does not appear to be much public exploration, debate over, and thorough dealing with the fundamental themes of public narratives and, even more critical, to understand and deal with the inherited archetypes of human subconscious that have, across millennia, influenced countless billions of people to repeatedly choose variants of the same core themes (“bad ideas”) to shape their personal and public narratives, the themes that satisfy their impulse for meaning and purpose. As I have often quoted Kristian Niemietz-

“Emotional satisfaction, not rational thinking, and despite contrary evidence, dominates our choice in beliefs.”

For the many that embrace of the same old themes, despite a long history of persistently and inevitably destructive outcomes, is because those familiar themes grant that “emotional satisfaction”. Hence, there is not much felt need to research more carefully the actual outcomes of such choices, or as is common today, the tribal impulse leads many to just defensively dismiss contrary evidence of damaging outcomes from their related policies by projecting that out as due to the contrary policies of their opponents.

This is not a denial of the authentic empathy or compassion that many in these collectivist movements feel toward more disadvantaged people but to recognize that empathy, as social psychologists like Gad Saad state, when taken to extremes can become “suicidal” and destructive, even ruining the lives of those who are the objects of compassion. We have the examples of the “safe supply” programs for homeless addicts that resulted in more deaths in places like Vancouver BC. Or the “catch and release” policies that freed repeat violent offenders and consequently resulted in further harm to innocent civilians. Or the misinformed ceasefires and standing down by Israeli politicians, intelligence agencies, and military out of the mistaken assumption that Hamas would turn to caring for the needs of Gazans. It appears that Israeli leaders did not fully grasp the true nature of Hamas’s commitment to the extermination of Jews and elimination of the state of Israel. Saad sites other examples.

In the Israel/Hamas situation it was a lack of appreciation for the real nature of what was driving Hamas- i.e. the inciting power of bad theology to overwhelm the humanity of people and energize them to violence toward differing others.

It is helpful to understand how impulses like empathy can become deformed and used by some for virtue-signalling as morally superior and hence validate people’s tendency to view themselves in terms of Zoroastrian dualism as the righteous ones on the true side as opposed to evil others who then must be eliminated for opposing the true believers who are serving the true God and trying to save the world from some imminent apocalypse.

However people view these things- i.e. the ongoing emergence of these never-ending collectivist and theocratic crusades- this site argues that the fundamental drivers (the core inciting/validating themes) are still embraced, protected, and dominant in major religious traditions and also in the secular/ideological variants.

Here is Grok’s summary of the main “bad ideas” themes this site has often posted:

One-page summary of the material

The “bad religious ideas” complex is a tightly linked set of themes that early humans projected from tribal, dominating, and retaliatory impulses onto gods or Ultimate Reality. It remains influential in both religious and secular narratives. At its center is a tribal, dominating, and punitively destroying God (or equivalent Ultimate Ideal). This image validates the rest, shields it from critique, and supplies emotional force: people tend to mirror the God or Ideal they hold.

Core supporting themes:

• Original paradise / golden age (past was better; fuels nostalgia for a non-existent state).

• The Fall / human corruption and anti-humanism (humans as essentially sinful, virus, or polluter).

• Declinism and human degeneration (downward trajectory; contradicts long-term evidence of reduced violence and rising well-being).

• Apocalyptic collapse (often imminent, with hell or eternal punishment adding terror; activates survival impulse).

• Salvation through sacrifice, payment, or destruction (angry gods demand appeasement; eye-for-eye justice; “salvation” via purging or de-growth).

• Deformed hero’s quest via cosmic dualism (good vs. evil split; outsiders as irredeemable threats; externalizes the real inner struggle; legitimizes exclusion, domination, and “exterminate or be exterminated” urgency).

• Restored utopia / millennial kingdom after purging…

And the alternative theology themes (also reposted from below):

Historical Jesus’ unconditional theology counters this at the center. In the Sermon material (Matt. 5:38–48; Luke 6:27–36), he rejects eye-for-eye, commands love of enemies, and grounds it in God’s character: God is kind to the ungrateful and wicked; sun and rain fall on good and evil alike; therefore “be merciful just as your Father is merciful.” The Nazareth synagogue episode (Luke 4) omits the vengeance clause from Isaiah 61 and cites mercy to outsiders, provoking fury. Parables (Prodigal Son, vineyard workers) dramatize the scandal of unconditional inclusion. He critiques the sacrifice/appeasement system and defines greatness as service, not domination.

This replaces the tribal/punitive God with non-retaliatory, no-conditions love/mercy. Supporting themes lose their ultimate authorization. The alternative complex: Ultimate Reality as non-threatening and inclusive; humanity as rising and creative rather than essentially fallen/degenerate; restorative rather than purely retributive justice; the primary battle as internal (against one’s own tribal/dominating/destructive impulses); trajectory of gradual improvement rather than decline-to-apocalypse; flourishing through love, service, inclusion, and ordinary human capacities rather than through purging or destruction. This reduces fear-driven hysteria, undercuts sacralized scapegoating and domination, and orients toward cooperation and long-term betterment without requiring the ruin of existing societies to “save” them.

(End of quotes from below)

Notes:

This site probes the core drivers of destructive movements like collectivism and presents the powerful alternative that goes to the core of all drivers, the core inciting and validating belief and ideal that when deformed by the wrong ideas then stirs our worst impulses to tribalism, domination, and destruction of differing others.

There is hope for the long-term transformation of public consciousness, hope is based on the deep and thorough transformation of human mind that involves the radical transformation of our personal narratives and belief systems, starting with the most central and fundament of all narrative themes- i.e. the nature of the ultimate reality, authority, or ideal that humans have long termed “God”. Transformation of that cohering center of human narratives then works throughout complexes ideas/beliefs to transform all other elements.

This is a call to full disintegration of inherited worldviews shaped by bad ideas and re-integration around “the stunning new theology” that, for example, historical Jesus presented. His basic Q Wisdom gospel and selected parables provide the basic themes/archetypes for an entirely new story for humanity.

Other notes:

The above arguments are not about rejecting one side (i.e. leftism) for a conversion to the other side, but about fundamental ideas/beliefs/themes that shape our thinking and emotions, that energize our motivations and consequent behavior, and policy choices we make and the subsequent direction our societies take.

The tribal thing of “liberal/conservative” divides, with their differing positions on political, economic, social and other issues, often clouds this critical element of core themes that are shared by both sides of such divides. And most critical to grapple with is the ultimate reality/ideal that centers most complexes of ideas, whether held by the right or the left. That makes the real battle of life against the real enemy of life an internal and personal thing.

Besides, both sides share the same basic themes of “salvation through destruction” of the differing others and their societies.

Grok, please rewrite and summarize the above opening posting for my site

Grok reply:

Here’s a rewritten and tightened version of your opening post. I’ve preserved the core arguments, evidence, and framing while improving structure, clarity, flow, and readability. Repetition is reduced, the language is more direct, and the piece moves more logically from immediate observations to the deeper analysis of ideas and the proposed alternative.

Ongoing Project

I read the news today, oh boy.

A recent Instagram post from Gad Saad and others (Nov 5) treated the U.S. election results as a warning of a potentially ruinous shift away from the basic institutions of liberal democracy toward collectivist and socialist alternatives. Similar patterns are visible across Western democracies in Europe, where governing leftist elites have moved toward more totalitarian forms of collectivism and, in some cases, accommodation of theocratic pressures. Dissenters and political opponents face censorship, silencing, and even criminalization in countries such as Germany and Britain.

These developments align with the “Red/Green” alliance: temporary tactical cooperation between certain collectivist or revolutionary left currents (“red”) and Islamist theocratic movements (“green”). Despite fundamental differences— secular materialist millenarianism versus religious apocalyptic dualism— both share the goal of weakening or destroying liberal democratic orders. Both rely on dualistic framing (chosen/pure versus irredeemable enemies), demand purification or revolutionary rupture, and treat existing societies as legitimate targets of destruction. Leading theocrats in Iran and similar actors have long encouraged or sponsored elements of this pattern.

A clear illustration of the green side of the alliance appears in Canada. Mohamed Fahmy has warned that the Muslim Brotherhood constitutes a “cancer” at the heart of the country; his Canada Act Now campaign documents its infiltration. As Michael Higgins summarized in the National Post (Nov 3): “Mohamed Fahmy’s Canada Act Now campaign is a warning about the Muslim Brotherhood infiltration of this country.”

Contemporary woke progressivism and DEI form another front in the broader collectivist project. This variant has moved through Western educational systems, indoctrinating successive generations in a manner consistent with the “long march through the institutions” that Chinese and Soviet strategists once described. History supplies a cautionary precedent: in 1979 Iran, leftists cooperated with theocrats as “useful idiots,” only to be eliminated once the theocrats consolidated power.

Many of us have assumed that liberal democracy’s record would make large-scale retreats into totalitarian collectivism or theocracy unlikely. Liberal democracy protects individual freedoms and rights against the centralization of power in state elites and bureaucracies. Friedrich Hayek showed how distributed power among competitive individuals and institutions (checks and balances) better restrains the domination impulse. Milton Friedman and others documented the concrete benefits of individual freedom and markets against the subordination of persons to collectivist control, always justified as serving “the greater good” as defined by a self-appointed elite after the manner of Plato’s philosopher-kings. The historical contrast is stark: repeated collectivist experiments have ruined societies, while liberal democratic free markets and individual rights have lifted billions out of poverty and continue to improve living standards.

Public discussion of the shift toward collectivism usually stays at the level of policy disagreements (Left/Right, Progressive/Conservative). Far less attention is given to the deeper narrative themes and inherited archetypes that shape personal and public stories across millennia. As Kristian Niemietz observed, “Emotional satisfaction, not rational thinking, and despite contrary evidence, dominates our choice in beliefs.” Familiar themes continue to satisfy that emotional need even when their outcomes are persistently destructive. Tribal loyalty then encourages people to dismiss contrary evidence by attributing harm to opponents rather than to their own preferred policies.

This is not a denial of genuine empathy or compassion among many who support collectivist programs. Social psychologists such as Gad Saad have noted, however, that empathy taken to extremes can become “suicidal” and destructive, including to the very people it intends to help. Examples include “safe supply” programs for homeless addicts that increased deaths in places such as Vancouver, “catch and release” policies that freed repeat violent offenders and produced further harm to civilians, and Israeli leaders’ mistaken assumption that Hamas would prioritize the welfare of Gazans once given breathing room. In the last case, a failure to grasp the inciting power of bad theology left leaders underestimating Hamas’s commitment to the extermination of Jews and the elimination of Israel.

Empathy can also be deformed into virtue-signaling that positions one’s group as the righteous side in a dualistic drama, legitimizing the elimination of those cast as irredeemable. The core drivers of these never-ending collectivist and theocratic crusades remain dominant in major religious traditions and in their secular/ideological variants.

At the center of this complex is a tribal, dominating, and punitively destroying image of Ultimate Reality (or its secular equivalent Ideal). This image sacralizes an “evil triad” of tribal dualism, domination, and punitive destruction of differing others. It externalizes the real inner struggle against those impulses, frames outsiders as existential threats, and repeatedly licenses “salvation through destruction.” Supporting themes include an original paradise or golden age, a Fall that renders humans essentially corrupt, declinism and degeneration, imminent apocalyptic collapse, salvation through sacrifice or purging, cosmic dualism that splits the world into pure and irredeemable, and a restored utopia achieved only after the destruction of existing societies.

Liberal democracy institutionalizes the contrasting alternative: non-tribal rules, due process, limited power, protected dissent, and peaceful transfers rather than purging. Historical Jesus’ teaching in the Sermon material (Matt. 5:38–48; Luke 6:27–36) and selected parables supplies a theological counter-center. He rejects eye-for-eye justice, commands love of enemies, and grounds the command in the character of God: kind to the ungrateful and wicked, sending sun and rain on good and evil alike. “Be merciful just as your Father is merciful.” The Nazareth synagogue episode omits the vengeance clause from Isaiah 61; parables such as the Prodigal Son and the vineyard workers dramatize unconditional inclusion.

This replaces the tribal/punitive center with non-retaliatory, no-conditions love and mercy. Supporting themes then lose their ultimate authorization. The alternative complex treats Ultimate Reality as non-threatening and inclusive, humanity as rising and creative rather than essentially fallen, justice as primarily restorative, the primary battle as internal, and the trajectory as gradual improvement rather than decline-to-apocalypse. Flourishing comes through love, service, inclusion, and ordinary human capacities rather than through purging.

The argument here is not a call to abandon one political side for the other. Both sides of the conventional liberal/conservative divide can share the same basic themes of “salvation through destruction” of differing others. The critical work is the transformation of personal narratives and belief systems, beginning with the most central theme of all: the nature of ultimate reality, authority, or ideal. Changing that cohering center works outward through the rest of the complex. There is long-term hope in the radical re-integration of inherited worldviews around the non-retaliatory alternative that historical Jesus presented. The real battle remains internal— against the tribal, dominating, and destructive impulses in oneself— rather than a permanent external crusade against irredeemable others.
Next:

Yes, do more on “Explain the Red/Green alliance”

Grok reply:

The Red/Green Alliance: A Tactical Convergence Against Liberal Democracy

The “Red/Green” alliance refers to temporary, tactical cooperation between certain collectivist or revolutionary left currents (“red”) and Islamist theocratic movements (“green”). The red side includes radical Marxists, socialists, anti-imperialists, and segments of contemporary progressivism. The green side consists of political Islamists— those pursuing the imposition of Islamic governance and sharia, most prominently networks linked to the Muslim Brotherhood and its offshoots (Hamas being the most prominent Palestinian example). Green does not refer here to environmentalist parties.

Despite deep incompatibilities, the two sides repeatedly find common cause. The left is secular and materialist, aiming at a classless or “decolonized” utopia. Islamists are theocratic and often apocalyptic, seeking religious supremacy. Their long-term visions are mutually exclusive. What unites them is a shared enemy: liberal democratic orders, capitalism, the West (especially the United States), and Israel. Both operate with dualistic framing— chosen or pure insiders versus irredeemable outsiders— and both treat existing liberal societies as legitimate targets for weakening or destruction.⁠ Blogs.timesofisrael⁠Meforum

The alliance is not primarily ideological fusion. It is pragmatic. The left supplies legitimacy, the language of social justice, decolonization, and human rights, and protection against criticism (often by labeling scrutiny of Islamism as “Islamophobia”). Islamists supply disciplined constituencies, numbers in certain immigrant communities, organizational infrastructure, and intense anti-Western energy. Each launders the other’s extremism. Shared master frames of anti-imperialism, anti-colonialism, and victim/oppressor narratives allow cooperation even when core values clash. ⁠Tandfonline

The Iranian precedent

The clearest historical illustration is the 1979 Iranian Revolution. Marxist groups (including the Tudeh Party), secular nationalists, and other leftists allied with Ayatollah Kuhollah Khomeini’s Islamists against the Shah under the banner of anti-imperialism and opposition to Western influence. Leftist participation helped mobilize opposition and gave the movement broader legitimacy, including among some Western intellectuals. Once the Shah fell and the Islamists consolidated power, they turned on their former allies. Communist organizations were dismantled; leftists were imprisoned, executed, or exiled. The theocrats eliminated the “useful idiots” who had helped them gain power. This pattern is repeatedly cited as a warning about the structural fragility of such alliances.⁠ Archive

Contemporary patterns

The same dynamic appears across Western liberal democracies:

• In Europe, far-left parties have courted Muslim voters and Islamist-linked networks, particularly around anti-Israel politics. Examples include elements of France’s La France Insoumise, certain UK left factions (especially during the Corbyn period), and segments of Green parties. Shared language of anti-imperialism and Palestinian solidarity masks deeper divergences; criticism of Islamist actors is often muted.⁠ Fox News

• In the United States, the pattern shows up in campus activism, progressive organizations, and electoral coalitions. Groups aligned with Students for Justice in Palestine or American Muslims for Palestine have overlapped with Democratic Socialists of America and other left currents in anti-Israel protests and BDS campaigns. Progressive framing of “decolonization” and resistance provides cover; Islamist networks gain platforms they would otherwise lack.

• In Canada, Mohamed Fahmy and reports from the Institute for the Study of Global Antisemitism and Policy (ISGAP) document Muslim Brotherhood-linked networks operating through charities, universities, civil-society groups, and electoral mobilization. Internal Brotherhood strategy documents (such as the 1991 “Explanatory Memorandum”) describe a “civilization-jihadist process” aimed at influencing Western societies from within. Entryism— gradual infiltration of institutions— is the preferred method rather than open confrontation. Canadian left and progressive circles have often amplified related narratives while downplaying the Brotherhood’s political aims.⁠ Nationalpost

Iran and other state actors have historically encouraged or sponsored elements of this cooperation where it serves anti-Western goals.

Shared operating logic

Both sides externalize internal struggles, frame outsiders as existential threats, and license purification or revolutionary rupture. Both draw on the older pattern of “salvation through destruction.” The left supplies the secular millenarian version (overthrow the system to reach utopia); the green side supplies the religious apocalyptic version (purge the ungodly). Liberal democracy— with its equal rules, due process, limited power, and protected dissent— stands in the way of both.

The alliance is unstable by nature. History shows that once the shared enemy is weakened, the green side has little incentive to tolerate the red side’s secularism, gender ideology, or rejection of religious authority. The Iranian outcome remains the clearest precedent.

This pattern is not a conspiracy theory about every leftist or every Muslim. It describes a documented, recurring tactical convergence between specific revolutionary-left currents and political Islamist networks, grounded in shared hostility to liberal democratic orders and a willingness to treat those orders as legitimate targets.

Next:

Do “Explore the 1991 Muslim Brotherhood memorandum” and the shared archetypes of these both essentially “profoundly religious crusades” just as Richard Landes exposed the essential religious nature of prominent Marxist themes.

Grok reply:

The 1991 Muslim Brotherhood Explanatory Memorandum

In May 1991, Mohamed Akram (also known as Mohammed Akram Adlouni), a senior figure in the Muslim Brotherhood’s North American operations and linked to Hamas networks, drafted “An Explanatory Memorandum on the General Strategic Goal for the Group in North America.” It was written for the Brotherhood’s Shura Council as a supplement to a long-term plan adopted in 1987. The document was discovered in 2004 during an FBI search of the Virginia home of Ismail Elbarasse (described by prosecutors as an archivist for the Brotherhood in America and a Hamas fundraiser). It was later entered as evidence in the Holy Land Foundation terrorism-financing trial. ⁠Investigativeproject

The memorandum’s core strategic goal, drawn from the 1987 plan, is the “Enablement of Islam in North America”: establishing an effective and stable Islamic Movement led by the Muslim Brotherhood. This movement would adopt Muslims’ causes domestically and globally, expand the observant base, unify and direct Muslim efforts, present Islam as a “civilization alternative,” and support the global Islamic state wherever it exists. ⁠Investigativeproject

The central mechanism is described as a “Civilization-Jihadist Process.” The most frequently cited passage states:

“The process of settlement is a “Civilization-Jihadist Process” with all the word means. The Ikhwan must understand that their work in America is a kind of grand Jihad in eliminating and destroying the Western civilization from within and “sabotaging” its miserable house by their hands and the hands of the believers so that it is eliminated and God’s religion is made victorious over all other religions. Without this level of understanding, we are not up to this challenge and have not prepared ourselves for Jihad yet. It is a Muslim’s destiny to perform Jihad and work wherever he is and wherever he lands until the final hour comes…⁠” Investigativeproject

“Settlement” is defined in practical terms: Islam and its Movement become part of the homeland, stable in the land, rooted in the spirits and minds of its people, and enabled in the life of society through firmly established organizations. The strategy emphasizes building institutions (Islamic centers as hubs), mastering coalitions, absorption, and cooperation, and shifting from caution to activism. An appendix listed organizations described as “our organizations and the organizations of our friends.”

There is debate over the memorandum’s status. Some analysts note that it appears aspirational in tone (“imagine if they all march according to one plan”) and that contemporaneous Brotherhood conference summaries do not explicitly record its formal adoption. Others observe that it was found in the archives of a key Brotherhood figure, that it is consistent with the group’s long-standing gradualist strategy of institutional embedding (entryism), and that it explicitly frames the work as a form of jihad aimed at civilizational replacement. Regardless of formal adoption status, the document articulates a coherent, long-term vision of dualistic civilizational struggle conducted through settlement and institutional means rather than open confrontation.⁠ Bridge.georgetown

Richard Landes and the Millennial Structure of “Secular” Crusades

Historian Richard Landes, in Heaven on Earth: The Varieties of the Millennial Experience (2011), argues that millennialism— the expectation of a radical, often imminent transformation of society into a perfect order through the annihilation of evil forces— is a cultural universal, not confined to traditional religions. He examines ten case studies outside Judaism and Christianity and shows that movements commonly treated as secular, including the French Revolution, Marxism, Bolshevism, and Nazism, contain core millennialist elements and follow what he calls the “apocalyptic curve”: enthusiastic launch, disappointment when predictions fail, and (often catastrophic) re-entry into ordinary time. ⁠Books.google

Landes treats Marxism as a form of egalitarian millennialism. Marx functions as a “rooster” (a prophet who announces the coming rupture). The present capitalist order is framed as a fallen, alienated condition that must be overcome. The revolutionary destruction of the bourgeoisie clears the path for the classless society— heaven on earth. Marx rejected the label of chiliast (millennialist) and insisted his analysis was scientific, yet the structure remains: withering critique of the existing civilization, prophecy of its annihilation, and the advent of a perfected social order. When the predicted timing fails, the framework is adjusted rather than abandoned. Bolshevism is analyzed as totalitarian millennialism that followed the same curve into coercive purity and terror. ⁠Academic.oup

Landes similarly analyzes Global Jihad as “enraged millennialism”: an active, cataclysmic apocalyptic movement aiming at a hierarchical millennium (the caliphate). Across these cases, the common features are dualistic framing (chosen/pure versus irredeemable enemies), the necessity of radical rupture, and the belief that the agents of the movement are instruments of historical or divine necessity.

Shared Archetypes: Profoundly Religious Crusades

The Red and Green currents of the alliance, despite their surface differences, draw on the same mythic structure that Landes identifies in millennial movements and that Krossa’s site has analyzed as the “bad ideas” complex centered on a tribal, dominating, and punitively destroying image of Ultimate Reality (or its secular equivalent Ideal).

• Dualistic cosmology: Both divide the world into the pure or chosen and the irredeemable other. For the red side, this is the proletariat (or the progressive/oppressed) versus the bourgeoisie, capitalists, or the West. For the green side, it is the believers versus the infidels or the “miserable house” of Western civilization. Outsiders are framed as existential threats rather than fellow humans subject to the same impulses.

• Declinism and the Fall: The existing order is corrupt, alienated, or in decline from a better past (or blocked from utopia). The memorandum’s language of a “miserable house” that must be sabotaged parallels the Marxist critique of capitalism as a system of alienation that must be destroyed.

• Apocalyptic urgency and salvation through destruction: Both license radical rupture. The red side promises the revolutionary annihilation of the old order to reach the classless society. The green side frames settlement and institutional work as a form of grand jihad that eliminates Western civilization so that “God’s religion is made victorious.” In both cases, destruction or purification of the differing other is the path to the restored ideal.

• Restored utopia / millennial kingdom: After the purge, a perfect order arrives— whether the egalitarian classless society or the enabled Islamic civilization supporting a global Islamic state. Both externalize the real inner struggle against tribal, dominating, and destructive impulses and project it onto external enemies who must be eliminated for the good to triumph.

• Sacred mission: Participants mirror the Ultimate Ideal they hold. The red side sacralizes historical necessity and the proletariat; the green side sacralizes Allah’s will and the community of believers. Emotional satisfaction derives from identifying with the righteous side in a cosmic drama, even when outcomes repeatedly prove destructive.

Landes’s analysis of Marxism and related secular movements demonstrates that the absence of traditional theistic language does not eliminate the religious structure. The 1991 memorandum supplies a concrete strategic document from the green side that explicitly uses the language of civilizational dualism, settlement as jihad, and the victory of one order over another. Together they illustrate why the Red/Green alliance can form tactically despite incompatible long-term visions: both are driven by the same core archetypes of dualism, declinism, and salvation through the destruction or replacement of the existing liberal democratic order.

These shared patterns explain the emotional power of the alliance and the difficulty of addressing it solely through policy debate. The deeper contest, as the site argues, concerns the central image of Ultimate Reality or Ideal that authorizes the rest of the complex.

Next:

Now do both your suggestions- “Explore Landes’ millennialism framework” and “Explore entryism tactics in Western politics”

My point in getting AI to repeatedly explore and explain this below is to illustrate how a complex of “bad religious ideas” long ago became the core archetypes of the human collective subconscious and repeatedly across history those archetypes have influenced succeeding generations of people to continue to embrace that same core set of ideas/beliefs to frame their narratives and worldviews, despite amassed evidence of bad outcomes where those archetypes incite people’s worst impulses to tribalism, domination of others, and vengeful violence toward differing others (eye for eye justice).

Grok reply:

Landes’ Millennialism Framework

Richard Landes, a medieval historian and specialist in apocalyptic movements, developed his framework in Heaven on Earth: The Varieties of the Millennial Experience (2011). He treats millennialism not as a fringe curiosity or something confined to traditional religions, but as a recurring, culturally universal pattern with distinctive dynamics and high historical impact. Secular historians, he argues, have systematically underestimated it because they view modern history as driven primarily by material or rational interests. ⁠Books.google

Millennialism, in Landes’ usage, is the belief that the current order is radically flawed and that a perfect society (“heaven on earth”) will arrive through the annihilation or decisive defeat of the forces of evil. This is usually accompanied by an apocalyptic sense of time— urgency, imminence, or historical necessity. He distinguishes several variables:

• Demotic/egalitarian versus imperial/hierarchical versions (bottom-up equality versus top-down rule by the elect).

• Progressive versus restorative (building something new versus recovering a golden age).

• Active cataclysmic (humans must destroy evil to clear the path) versus more passive or transformative expectations.

• The “apocalyptic curve”: enthusiastic launch → disappointment when predictions fail → re-entry into ordinary time (often via terror, coercion, or quiet abandonment of the original vision).

Landes deliberately examines cases outside Judaism and Christianity to show the pattern’s adaptability. Marxism is analyzed as egalitarian millennialism. Marx functions as a “rooster” (a prophet who announces the coming rupture). Capitalism is the fallen, alienated present; the revolutionary destruction of the bourgeoisie clears the way for the classless society. Marx rejected the chiliast label and insisted his system was scientific, yet the structure remains: withering critique of the existing civilization, prophecy of its annihilation, and the advent of a perfected order. When timing fails, the framework is adjusted rather than discarded.

Bolshevism is treated as totalitarian millennialism that followed the curve into coercive purity. The French Revolution appears as democratic millennialism; Nazism as genocidal millennialism; Global Jihad as enraged millennialism aiming at a hierarchical caliphate. ⁠Academic.oup

The framework highlights shared psychological and social drivers: dualistic framing (chosen/pure versus irredeemable enemies), externalization of inner struggles onto external threats, and the emotional power of identifying with the righteous agents of historical or divine necessity. These features explain why millennial movements can form temporary alliances of convenience even when their ultimate visions are incompatible. They also explain the repeated pattern of disappointment followed by either retreat or intensified purification.

Entryism Tactics in Western Politics

Entryism is the tactic of infiltrating existing organizations, institutions, or movements from within in order to influence, redirect, or ultimately control them, rather than confronting them openly. It has a long history on the revolutionary left (especially among Trotskyists, who used it to enter larger socialist or labor parties). In the Red/Green context, it appears in both secular collectivist and Islamist forms.

On the Islamist side, the Muslim Brotherhood’s long-term strategy of gradual institutional embedding is a classic form of entryism. The 1991 Explanatory Memorandum frames this as “settlement”: rooting an Islamic movement in the host society so that it becomes stable, organizationally established, and able to present Islam as a civilization alternative. The preferred methods are building or influencing institutions (Islamic centers, charities, advocacy groups, student organizations), forming coalitions, practicing “absorption,” and working through existing democratic and civil-society structures rather than open confrontation.

The goal is influence from within so that Western civilization is gradually “sabotaged” by the hands of those inside it. Contemporary reports (including ISGAP analyses of Canada) describe this pattern in universities, charities, electoral mobilization, and bureaucratic networks, often under the banners of anti-Islamophobia, Palestinian solidarity, or community advocacy. ⁠Nationalpost

On the red/left side, entryism has taken both older and newer forms. Classic Trotskyist entryism targeted larger left parties. In recent decades, a related pattern appears in the “long march through the institutions”: gradual capture of educational systems, cultural institutions, bureaucracies, and nonprofits by progressive or collectivist frameworks (including DEI variants). Once inside, these actors shift institutional norms, language, hiring, and policy priorities.

The Red/Green alliance multiplies the effect: left entryists provide legitimacy and protective language (“Islamophobia,” decolonization, social justice), while Islamist networks supply organizational discipline, demographic constituencies in certain areas, and anti-Western energy. Joint activity is most visible in campus activism, anti-Israel campaigns, and electoral coalitions where progressive parties or factions court specific voter blocs.

Shared operational features include:

• Preference for institutional and cultural influence over frontal assault.

• Use of existing liberal democratic openness (free speech, academic freedom, charitable status, coalition politics) as the vehicle.

• Dualistic framing that treats criticism of the entryist project as evidence of the enemy’s corruption.

• Mutual laundering: each side’s extremism is softened by association with the other.

Landes’ framework and entryism tactics reinforce each other. Millennial movements generate the dualistic urgency and sense of sacred mission that make long-term entryism emotionally sustainable. Entryism supplies the practical method for advancing the millennial project inside open societies without triggering immediate collapse or full resistance.

Both the red and green currents, in this reading, operate as profoundly religious (or mythic) crusades whose surface differences do not eliminate the shared archetypes of dualism, declinism, and salvation through the transformation or destruction of the existing liberal order. The Iranian precedent remains the clearest historical warning that the green side has previously discarded red allies once the shared enemy was sufficiently weakened.

This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.