God as tribal, dominating, and destroyer of unbelievers, energizes and validates the same in followers

Grok below on how the “stunning new unconditional theology” of Historical Jesus overturns the fundamental beliefs of the conditional religions of Western civilization, notably Jewish religion, Christianity, and Islam.

Then as psychologist Harold Ellens argues, sick God images produce sick people who think, feel, and act similarly to the God that they believe in (i.e. imitating the tribal exclusion of differing others, domination of the lesser others, and vengeful destruction of the demonized others).

Grok states below- “The stunning new theology of Jesus was not a minor ethical tweak. It replaced the cohering center of the old religious complexes of beliefs”.

The theological breakthrough of Jesus called for a radical transformation of how people viewed God. It called for the complete disintegration of the old religious belief systems and urged re-integration around the entirely new center of an unconditional God.

These quotes from below (Grok is summarizing the main points/arguments of this site): “The Tribal God and the Unconditional Alternative: How Historical Jesus Counters a Persistent Complex of Destructive Ideas

“Human narratives have long been shaped by a tightly linked set of ideas that originated in early myth-making and have continued to influence both religious traditions and many secular ideologies. At the center of this complex stands a particular image of Ultimate Reality: a tribal, dominating, and punitively destroying God. This image does not merely sit alongside the other themes; it validates them, energizes them, and protects them from serious challenge. The result has been repeated patterns of fear, exclusion, scapegoating, and “salvation through destruction.”

“A different framing appears in the teachings most widely attributed to the historical Jesus. By replacing the tribal and punitive image of God with one of non-retaliatory, no-conditions mercy and love— even toward enemies and outsiders— these teachings undercut the supporting structure of the older complex and offer an alternative set of themes oriented toward inclusion, restoration, and gradual improvement.”

And…

“The Tribal God as the Cohering Center

“The element that holds the complex together and gives it emotional and social force is the image of God (or Ultimate Reality) as tribal, dominating, and punitively destroying.

“This God favors one group— the true believers, the pure, the chosen— and is hostile or indifferent to outsiders. It embodies and authorizes the impulse to dominate weaker others. It responds to failure, difference, or impurity with retaliation, vengeance, judgment, exclusion, and destruction. It demands appeasement through sacrifice or payment. Because this image is treated as the ultimate authority and as essentially immutable, the rest of the complex is shielded from ordinary criticism. Challenging it feels like blasphemy or an attack on the foundations of meaning and identity.

“People tend to mirror the God they worship or the Ultimate Ideal they hold. As Harold Ellens and Zenon Lotufo have argued, a “cruel God” or “monster God” image— wrathful, requiring bloody satisfaction, ready to destroy— supplies psychological permission for violence and domination (“If your God uses force, then so may you”). It also produces the guilt, shame, and anxiety that make populations receptive to elite control and apocalyptic crusades. Even many who reject formal religion continue to operate with residual versions of the same punitive or threat-based framing of Ultimate Reality; the critique often assumes no genuine alternative is possible.

“The tribal God therefore functions as both the origin and the protector of the complex. It turns ordinary human impulses— tribal preference, status competition, retaliation— into sacred duties. It makes dualistic division, purity-driven exclusion, and salvation-through-destruction feel like obedience rather than pathology…

“Jesus’ Counter-Narrative

“The teachings most consistently attributed to the historical Jesus directly challenge this central image and the behaviors it authorizes. The core material appears in the parallels of the Sermon on the Mount and Sermon on the Plain (Matthew 5:38–48 and Luke 6:27–36), widely regarded by scholars as among the earliest and most distinctive layers of the tradition.

“Jesus rejects the principle of eye-for-eye retaliation. He commands love of enemies, blessing of those who curse, and prayer for persecutors. He grounds the command in the character of God: God is kind to the ungrateful and the wicked; God causes the sun to rise on the evil and the good and sends rain on the righteous and the unrighteous. Therefore, “be merciful, just as your Father is merciful.” Love that extends only to one’s own group is ordinary; the distinctive requirement is love that includes enemies and outsiders. This is presented not as an optional supererogatory ideal but as the imitation of Ultimate Reality itself.”

“The Nazareth synagogue episode (Luke 4) illustrates the same move in narrative form. Jesus reads from Isaiah 61 and stops at the proclamation of the year of the Lord’s favor, omitting the expected note of vengeance. He then cites examples of God’s mercy extended to outsiders— the widow of Zarephath and Naaman the Syrian— provoking fury and an attempt to kill him. The reaction matches what would be expected when a validating tribal and punitive theology is publicly refused. The parables of the Prodigal Son and the vineyard workers further dramatize the scandal of unconditional inclusion: those invested in conditional, retaliatory accounting are angered by generosity that does not keep score.

“Additional elements reinforce the counter. Jesus critiques the temple sacrifice system that rested on the logic of appeasing an offended deity. He defines greatness as service rather than domination or lording over others. The emphasis falls on forgiveness, inclusion of the marginalized, and the transformation of the heart rather than the violent purging of external enemies. The primary struggle is internal— against the impulses that produce tribal exclusion, domination, and destructive retaliation— rather than an external war against demonized others.

“This is not a minor ethical refinement of existing religion. It replaces the cohering center. Where the older complex pictured Ultimate Reality as tribal and punitive, the Jesus material pictures it as non-retaliatory and no-conditions in its mercy and love. The supporting themes lose their ultimate authorization.”

(End of Grok quotes from below)

This insert:

Gail on her discovery of a God who serves and does not lord over people. This is a radical new imaging of theology, that states there is no superior sky or heaven God above who dictates down to life. To the contrary, God is immediately/immanently present with everyone. God is within all, equally (i.e. closer than our breath or atoms).

And more profound, there is no God as Lord or King who coercively intervenes in life, overruling human freedom and choice. Quite the opposite, God is present to serve all of us with “gentle persuasion” (perhaps explaining the personally felt urges often attributed to activated human conscience?).

God is the “Fellow Sufferer” of Process theology who absorbs the details of every human experience into God’s self, eternally. Nothing anyone suffers is forgotten or discarded.

This quote from my sister Gail: “The paragraph on God as servant blows me away. I get God suffering with us and learning with us, etc. But as a servant is another level for me – a long way from the austere Being on a throne and even from the “Father” concept, though that is closer. A true father does serve in love. To be served by God is another connotation for me and very humbling.”

This was in response to the Jesus’ teaching that true greatness was to not lord over others but to serve others. And God is great, right? Truly great leaders serve others as in the principles and institutions of liberal democracy/Classic Liberalism.

The takeaway is that there is no dominating God who intervenes in life to override natural consequences and laws but instead God respects freedom or God would not be love (i.e. authentic love respects and cannot overrule the freedom of others or it would not be love).

Other points derived from this– If we are really “one with God” (as per NDE accounts) then this cosmos, world, and life is a co-creation by us with God. And yes, divine transcendence still applies in that.

Conclusions: Islam got God all wrong. It got “greatness” all wrong just as Paul got it wrong with his “Lord Christ” ruling all with “a rod of iron” totalitarianism. Paul rejected the greatness that had been taught by Jesus two decades earlier, true greatness as serving others.

Carl Jung was then right that “religions got God all wrong”. Christians, in particular, should have known better on this element of true greatness. If they really believed that Jesus was God, or manifested God, then what was he doing washing the feet of others, if not to illustrate that God serves people?

Anyway, regarding these stunning new images of deity, let the blasphemy roll on. It breaks the mind free of enslaving religious threat to imagine entirely new ways of imaging the great Mystery of God. Varied commentators have written on the benefits of blasphemy.

“Robert Fulford: In praise of blasphemy: Without the courage of those who were called blasphemers there would be only one acceptable religion in every country today”, Robert Fulford, Sep 22, 2012

https://nationalpost.com/opinion/robert-fulford-in-praise-of-blasphemy

Quotes:

“The dark, blood-drenched word ‘blasphemy’ has lately re-appeared across the world, like some grotesque monster from the depths of humanity’s unconscious. It is always bad news, the prelude to unnecessary suffering.”

He references a video of decades ago that some Muslims called blasphemous that then drove other Muslims into a frenzy where people died in riots to protest the alleged offense against the prophet.

Fulford continues…

“For centuries, unspeakable crimes have been committed in the name of regulating what people say about religion. During the long Catholic nightmare of the Spanish Inquisition the ecclesiastical authorities competed in devising punishments for those with unauthorized religious views. Boring a hole in the tongue with a hot wire was a common penalty. Laws against blasphemy have been favourite tools of all those who lust for power over their fellow humans — popes, kings, bishops, imams, theologians and professional inciters of the mobs.

“A charge of blasphemy works as a screen hiding the schemes of would-be rulers who dream of Taliban-level dictatorships.”

Following other examples, notably from the Muslim world, Fulford concludes:

“Instead, we should be praising blasphemy, in fact proclaiming its many virtues, rather than sheepishly apologizing for it as a necessary evil we must reluctantly tolerate because of our belief in the freedom of speech.

“Bernard Shaw may have been overstating the case when he gave to one of his characters the pronouncement that ‘All great truths begin as blasphemies.’ But not by much.” (End of Fulford article)

Bob Brinsmead has also written on this issue– “Dare to Blaspheme and Dare to be Free”

AI Overview:

“Dare to Blaspheme and Dare to Be Free” is a radical theological essay written by Australian thinker Robert “Bob” Daniel Brinsmead. It was published in 1989 as part of Quest, Essay 1, marking the culmination of his dramatic departure from traditional, orthodox religion.

Once a prominent and highly controversial Seventh-day Adventist theologian, Brinsmead used this essay to articulate a shift toward a deeply humanistic, “horizontal” understanding of spirituality.

The Core Theme: The “Liberating Power” of Blasphemy

In the essay, Brinsmead redefines “blasphemy” not as an offensive sin against a deity, but as a necessary act of psychological and spiritual liberation.

• Smashing the Vertical Hierarchy: Brinsmead argues that traditional Christianity presents God as an absolute, “vertical” dictator sitting at the top of a massive religious bureaucracy. He asserts that this vertical model validates human oppression, autocracy, and religious control.

• The Example of Jesus: He posits that Jesus himself was a radical who came to demolish this vertical dimension of religion. According to Brinsmead, Jesus viewed the exercise of vertical authority as inherently pagan and destructive to the human spirit.

• The Priority of the Horizontal: The core thesis is that human responsibility and love on a horizontal level (human to human) must take priority over all vertical religious devotion.

To achieve full human freedom, Brinsmead argues that individuals must “dare to blaspheme”— meaning they must intentionally reject, challenge, and break free from the abusive, authoritarian god-concepts imposed by institutionalized religion.

Context Within Brinsmead’s Theological Journey

To understand the weight of Dare to Blaspheme, it helps to look at the massive shifts in Brinsmead’s life:

1. The 1960s (Perfectionism): He led the “Sanctuary Awakening” movement, preaching a hyper-strict, perfectionist form of Adventism.

2. The 1970s (Mainstream Protestantism): He abandoned his early views to champion Martin Luther’s concept of “faith alone,” editing the widely read magazine Present Truth.

3. The 1980s onward (Liberalism & Humanism): He entirely discarded orthodox Christian tenets (including the divinity of Christ and the institutional church), transitioning into a highly progressive, earth-centric philosophy.

Dare to Blaspheme and Dare to Be Free represents the final stage of this evolution, where he walked away from organized religion entirely to focus on humanism, politics, and eco-farming.

(End of AI Overview on Brinsmead)

One more insert:

I usually invite the AI to put forth their counter points to new material that I am posting, but I’ve gotten a bit tired with that due to what I view as their excessive woke leftist leanings as per the Washington Post report of the past summer. That may explain why, with all their caveats and qualifiers, they end sometimes clarifying nothing much about the profound contrast between good and evil in religious traditions that is central to what I am trying to clarify- i.e. that yes, there are diamonds among the dung elements of major religions, diamonds often in mergers with dung (i.e. Paul’s merger of Historical Jesus with his opposite Christ) where the good is weakened by the mixed contexts and the bad is elevated as something good, or “cloaked as good”.

The outcome of those AI summaries is that clear distinctions are not made between bad and good. Hence, bad ideas, presented as divinely inspired in religious holy books, continue to shape human minds and emotions, and energize human motivations to horrific outcomes of bad behavior toward others. The AI have a ways to go yet to understand what it means to be human.

My prompt: Grok, please summarize the “bad religious ideas” list below and its points. Also, add more that may help illustrate this list. Then show how the unconditional theology and message of Historical Jesus counters these bad ideas and gives us another alternative complex of themes to frame human narratives in better ways with better outcomes. Thanks.

Grok reply:

The “bad religious ideas” complex is a tightly interwoven set of primitive mythic themes, centered on a tribal, dominating, and punitively destroying God, that still shape both religious and many secular narratives.

These ideas originated as early humans projected their animal impulses (tribalism, domination of others, and punitive destruction of rivals) onto spirits/gods and used those images to explain and justify their world. The central “monster God” (Harold Ellens, Zenon Lotufo) validated the rest, rendering the complex “sacred” and resistant to challenge. The themes include:

1. Original paradise / golden age — The past was better (Eden, Dilmun, pristine wilderness). This fuels rosy retrospection and nostalgia for a state that geological and historical evidence shows never existed.

2. The Fall / human corruption — Early humans erred, ruined the paradise, and became essentially sinful or destructive (anti-humanism). Humans are framed as the virus, cancer, or polluter of a pure creation. This intensifies guilt, shame, and the sense that people deserve punishment.

3. Declinism — Life and civilization decline toward worse conditions (Arthur Herman). This breeds fatalism, anxiety, and resignation.

4. Human degeneration — Humanity itself becomes worse over time (“noble savage” contrast, original sin extended). This contradicts long-term evidence of reduced violence and improving indicators of well-being (Payne, Pinker, Simon).

5. Apocalyptic collapse — Decline ends in catastrophic destruction, often divine judgment, frequently “imminent.” This activates the survival impulse, making people susceptible to irrational “salvation” schemes. Hell or eternal punishment piles metaphysical terror on physical fears.

6. Salvation through sacrifice, payment, or destruction — Angry gods demand appeasement (blood, suffering, de-growth, purging). Justice is eye-for-eye/retributive. Mendel’s warning applies: beware any salvation promised through destruction.

7. Deformed hero’s quest via cosmic dualism — Zoroastrian-style good vs. evil splits the world into pure insiders and irredeemable outsiders. Differing others are demonized as existential threats requiring purification or extermination. This externalizes the real struggle (inner animal impulses) and legitimizes domination, tribal conflict, and “exterminate or be exterminated” urgency when apocalypse is thought imminent. Elites or “chosen” gatekeepers claim special authority.

8. Restored utopia / millennial kingdom — After purging, a paradise, communal ideal, or new order is restored (religious or secular variants: collectivist, environmental “return to nature,” etc.).

These produce the “madness of crowds,” endless crusades of salvation-through-destruction, deformed personalities (guilt, shame, fear), and policies that harm societies. They appear in major religions (which still claim the affiliation of most of humanity) and in secular forms (climate alarmism, certain political millenarianisms, AI doomerism). The unaffiliated or “spiritual but not religious” often retain the same archetypes.

Much more in this link…

Additional illustrating themes that fit the complex:

• Purity/pollution codes that demand coercive cleansing of the “defiled.”

• Hierarchical cosmic order that sacralizes social domination and the elite/commoner divide (alpha-ism projected upward).

• Scapegoating mechanisms in which violence against a victim is believed to restore order or appease the divine.

• Prophetic certainty and date-setting that keep populations in perpetual crisis mode.

• Blood atonement or penal substitution as the necessary cosmic transaction (Anselmian frameworks and their secular echoes).

• The fusion of tribal exceptionalism (“chosen”) with punitive justice, which scales ordinary rivalry into metaphysical warfare.

Historical Jesus’ unconditional theology and message counters this complex at its center and offers an alternative set of themes.

The reconstructed core of Jesus’ teaching (especially the Q material and the Sermon on the Mount/Plain parallels) rejects the punitive, tribal God and the eye-for-eye framework that held the old complex together. In Luke 4 he reads Isaiah 61 but stops at “the year of the Lord’s favor,” omitting the vengeance clause, then cites God’s mercy to outsiders (widow of Zarephath, Naaman the Syrian). The synagogue audience is furious and tries to kill him— exactly the reaction expected when the validating tribal/punitive God is challenged.

In Matthew 5:38–48 and Luke 6:27–36 he explicitly overturns “eye for eye,” commands love of enemies, and grounds it in the character of God: God is kind to the ungrateful and wicked, sends sun and rain on the good and the evil, and people are to “be merciful just as your Father is merciful.” The Prodigal Son and vineyard workers parables illustrate the scandal of unconditional inclusion that enrages those invested in conditional, retaliatory justice. He critiques the sacrifice system that rested on appeasement of an angry deity and models greatness as service rather than lording over others.

This is not a minor ethical tweak. It replaces the cohering center of the old complex. The alternative complex of themes that follows is:

• Ultimate reality as non-retaliatory, no-conditions love/mercy — Inclusive, not tribal; restorative rather than punitive. No ultimate threat, exclusion, or destruction. All are ultimately safe.

• Humanity as rising, creative, and essentially capable of goodness — Not fallen and degenerating, but improving over the long term. The real story is ascent from animal impulses through learning, commerce, empathy, and creativity (Simon’s “more creators than destroyers”).

• Justice as restorative and inclusive — Love of enemies, forgiveness, inclusion of outsiders. The battle of good and evil is primarily internal (against one’s own tribal, dominating, and destructive impulses), not an external war against demonized others.

• Trajectory of improvement, not decline to apocalypse — Hope grounded in evidence of long-term betterment rather than mythical restoration after collapse. Gradual democratic processes preferred over “instantaneous purging.”

• Salvation/flourishing through love, service, and ongoing creation — Not through sacrifice, destruction, or elite-enforced purification. True greatness is service; the hero’s quest is inner transformation and outward inclusion.

• Fundamental human oneness — Common origins, shared humanity, and (in some framings) deeper metaphysical unity undercut dualistic tribalism and chosen-people exceptionalism.

These alternative themes produce different emotions, motivations, and outcomes: reduced fear and survival hysteria, less scapegoating and violence, greater inclusion and cooperation, healthier personalities free of excessive guilt/shame from a “monster God,” and policies oriented toward actual improvement rather than self-destructive “salvation” schemes. They do not deny imperfection or the need for accountability, but they refuse to sacralize retribution, dualism, or decline.

The old complex has dominated for millennia precisely because its central God image was treated as immutable and unchallengeable. Jesus’ move— questioning and replacing that image— remains the most direct counter. Whether or not one accepts every detail of historical reconstruction, the documented radicalism of the love-of-enemies teaching and its grounding in a non-retaliatory God offers a coherent alternative framing that has repeatedly been diluted or reversed (as the user notes with Paul) when re-merged with the older punitive and apocalyptic themes. The practical test is which complex more consistently supports human flourishing without requiring the destruction of existing societies to “save” them.

(End of Grok comments)

Next:

Lets try your suggestions- Give me the full list with my original points, Explain the tribal God concept, and Show how this counters the bad ideas.

Grok again:

Full list of the “bad religious ideas” complex (original points from Wendell Krossa, expanded with related themes that illustrate the same pattern)

The complex is held together by one central image: a tribal, dominating, and punitively destroying God. That image supplies the ultimate authority and emotional energy for everything else. The supporting themes are:

1. Original paradise / golden age

The past was better (Eden, Dilmun, pristine wilderness with few humans). This creates longing for a state that geological and historical evidence shows never existed and feeds rosy retrospection.

2. The Fall / human corruption and anti-humanism

Early perfect humans committed an original error, ruined the paradise, and left all subsequent humanity essentially sinful or destructive. Humans become the virus, cancer, or polluter of nature. This intensifies unnecessary guilt and shame beyond ordinary awareness of imperfection.

3. Declinism

Life and civilization are on a downward trajectory toward worse conditions. This produces fatalism, anxiety, and the sense that effort is ultimately pointless.

4. Human degeneration

Humanity itself becomes worse over time. The “noble savage” contrast and extended original-sin thinking follow from this. It contradicts long-term evidence of declining violence and rising material and social well-being.

5. Apocalyptic collapse and final destruction

Decline ends in catastrophic ending, often presented as divine judgment and frequently treated as imminent. Hell or eternal punishment adds metaphysical terror. The combination activates the survival impulse and makes people susceptible to irrational “salvation” schemes.

6. Salvation through sacrifice, payment, or destruction

Angry gods require appeasement (blood, suffering, de-growth, purging). Justice is defined as eye-for-eye/retributive. Any promised salvation that comes via destruction fits this pattern.

7. Deformed hero’s quest via cosmic dualism

A good God/force wars eternally against an evil force. Insiders must join the true side and fight the false side. Differing others are demonized as irredeemable existential threats. When the end is thought imminent, this legitimizes “exterminate or be exterminated” urgency and elite gatekeeping. The real internal struggle against one’s own animal impulses is externalized onto other people.

8. Restored utopia or millennial kingdom

After the purging comes the restored paradise, communal ideal, or new perfect order (religious or secular variants).

Related illustrating themes that reinforce the same complex:

• Purity/pollution codes that demand coercive cleansing of the “defiled.”

• Hierarchical cosmic order that sacralizes social domination and the elite/commoner divide.

• Scapegoating in which violence against a victim is believed to restore order or satisfy the divine.

• Prophetic certainty and repeated date-setting that keep populations in perpetual crisis mode.

• Blood atonement or penal substitution as the necessary cosmic transaction.

• Tribal exceptionalism (“chosen”) fused with punitive justice, which turns ordinary rivalry into metaphysical warfare.

These themes appear in major religious traditions and in many secular ideologies. They distort the actual long-term trajectory of life, generate excessive fear and guilt, and repeatedly produce “salvation through destruction” movements.

The tribal God concept

The cohering center is a God (or Ultimate Reality) pictured as tribal, dominating, and punitively destroying. This God:

• Favors one group (the true believers, the chosen, the pure) and is hostile or indifferent to outsiders.

• Embodies and authorizes the impulse to dominate weaker others.

• Responds to human failure or difference with retaliation, vengeance, judgment, exclusion, and destruction.

• Demands appeasement, sacrifice, or payment to avert punishment.

• Makes the entire complex feel like sacred, unchallengeable truth. Questioning the God image itself is treated as blasphemy or existential threat.

Because people tend to mirror the God they worship or the Ultimate Ideal they hold, this image supplies psychological permission for tribal exclusion, domination, and violence (“If your God uses force, then so may you”). It also generates the guilt, shame, and fear that make populations receptive to elite control and apocalyptic crusades. Harold Ellens and Zenon Lotufo describe the resulting “cruel God” or “monster God” image and its effects on personality and culture. The image is rarely questioned even by many who reject formal religion; the critique usually assumes no alternative conception of Ultimate Reality is possible.

How the unconditional theology and message of Historical Jesus counters these bad ideas

Jesus’ core teaching replaces the central God image and thereby undercuts the supporting themes. The key statements are the rejection of eye-for-eye, the command to love enemies, and the grounding of that command in God’s own character (Matthew 5:38–48; Luke 6:27–36): God is kind to the ungrateful and the wicked; he sends sun and rain on the good and the evil; therefore “be merciful just as your Father is merciful.” In the Nazareth synagogue (Luke 4) he reads Isaiah 61 but stops at the year of the Lord’s favor (omitting the vengeance clause) and then cites God’s mercy to outsiders (the Sidonian widow and Naaman the Syrian), which enrages the audience. The Prodigal Son and vineyard workers parables dramatize the same scandal of unconditional inclusion. He critiques the sacrifice system that rested on appeasement and defines greatness as service rather than domination.

This produces a direct set of counters:

• Against the tribal, punitive God: Ultimate Reality is non-retaliatory and no-conditions love/mercy. There is no ultimate threat, exclusion, or destruction. The validating center of the old complex is removed.

• Against original paradise + Fall + anti-humanism: Humanity is not an essentially corrupted destroyer of a lost perfect world. The emphasis shifts to the long rise out of animal impulses and the capacity for goodness and creativity.

• Against declinism and human degeneration: The framing becomes one of gradual improvement rather than inevitable decline. Hope is not dependent on mythical restoration after collapse.

• Against apocalyptic terror and salvation-through-destruction: No ultimate punitive ending is required. Justice is restorative rather than retributive. The survival impulse is no longer stoked by imminent divine destruction, reducing susceptibility to schemes that ruin societies to “save” them.

• Against the deformed hero’s quest and cosmic dualism: The primary battle is internal (against one’s own tribal, dominating, and destructive impulses). Differing others are not irredeemable enemies to be purged. Inclusion and love of enemies replace “exterminate or be exterminated.”

• Against domination and elite gatekeeping: True greatness is service, not lording over others. No special class is authorized by a tribal God to control the rest.

• Against the demand for sacrifice and retributive payment: Unconditional mercy renders the old appeasement economy unnecessary. Forgiveness and inclusion replace eye-for-eye as the model of justice.

The resulting alternative complex of themes is coherent: a non-threatening Ultimate Reality; humanity as rising and creative rather than fallen and degenerate; restorative justice and inclusion; an internal rather than external hero’s quest; and improvement through ordinary human capacities rather than through purging or destruction. Outcomes differ because the emotions and motivations differ— less fear-driven hysteria, less scapegoating, greater willingness to cooperate across differences, and policies oriented toward actual long-term betterment instead of self-destructive salvation schemes.

The old complex has persisted because its God image was treated as immutable. Jesus’ move was to question and replace that image at the center. The practical difference is visible in which set of themes more consistently supports human flourishing without requiring the ruin of existing societies.

(End of Grok comment)

Next:

OK, how about Give me a full article on this, Explore Jesus’ counter-narrative, and Show the tribal God concept and how it counters bad ideas.

Grok’s next:

The Tribal God and the Unconditional Alternative: How Historical Jesus Counters a Persistent Complex of Destructive Ideas

Human narratives have long been shaped by a tightly linked set of ideas that originated in early myth-making and have continued to influence both religious traditions and many secular ideologies. At the center of this complex stands a particular image of Ultimate Reality: a tribal, dominating, and punitively destroying God. This image does not merely sit alongside the other themes; it validates them, energizes them, and protects them from serious challenge. The result has been repeated patterns of fear, exclusion, scapegoating, and “salvation through destruction.”

A different framing appears in the teachings most widely attributed to the historical Jesus. By replacing the tribal and punitive image of God with one of non-retaliatory, no-conditions mercy and love— even toward enemies and outsiders— these teachings undercut the supporting structure of the older complex and offer an alternative set of themes oriented toward inclusion, restoration, and gradual improvement.

The Bad Ideas Complex and Its Central Image

The complex can be summarized in a set of interlocking themes that early humans constructed as they projected their own impulses onto the gods and used those projections to explain the world.

An original paradise or golden age is imagined in the past. Early humans then commit an original error that corrupts them and ruins the paradise, rendering subsequent generations essentially sinful or destructive. Life thereafter declines. Humanity itself degenerates. The trajectory ends in catastrophic apocalyptic destruction, frequently presented as divine judgment and often treated as imminent, with hell or eternal punishment adding further terror. Salvation requires sacrifice, payment, or purging to appease the angry deity and rebalance cosmic justice defined as eye-for-eye. The hero’s quest is deformed by cosmic dualism: a good force wars against an evil force, so true believers must identify and destroy the irredeemable outsiders who threaten existence. After the purging comes the restored utopia or millennial order.

Related reinforcing themes include purity codes that demand coercive cleansing, hierarchical cosmic orders that sacralize social domination, scapegoating mechanisms, prophetic date-setting that sustains crisis, blood atonement or penal substitution as the necessary transaction, and the fusion of “chosen” exceptionalism with punitive justice.

These ideas did not remain confined to ancient myth. They reappear in major religious traditions and in modern forms— certain political millenarianisms, environmental alarmism that treats modern civilization as the destroyer of a pure nature, and other “salvation through destruction” narratives. They distort the actual long-term record of human improvement, generate excessive guilt and fear, and repeatedly license movements that damage societies in the name of saving them.

The Tribal God as the Cohering Center

The element that holds the complex together and gives it emotional and social force is the image of God (or Ultimate Reality) as tribal, dominating, and punitively destroying.

This God favors one group— the true believers, the pure, the chosen— and is hostile or indifferent to outsiders. It embodies and authorizes the impulse to dominate weaker others. It responds to failure, difference, or impurity with retaliation, vengeance, judgment, exclusion, and destruction. It demands appeasement through sacrifice or payment. Because this image is treated as the ultimate authority and as essentially immutable, the rest of the complex is shielded from ordinary criticism. Challenging it feels like blasphemy or an attack on the foundations of meaning and identity.

People tend to mirror the God they worship or the Ultimate Ideal they hold. As Harold Ellens and Zenon Lotufo have argued, a “cruel God” or “monster God” image— wrathful, requiring bloody satisfaction, ready to destroy— supplies psychological permission for violence and domination (“If your God uses force, then so may you”). It also produces the guilt, shame, and anxiety that make populations receptive to elite control and apocalyptic crusades. Even many who reject formal religion continue to operate with residual versions of the same punitive or threat-based framing of Ultimate Reality; the critique often assumes no genuine alternative is possible.

The tribal God therefore functions as both the origin and the protector of the complex. It turns ordinary human impulses— tribal preference, status competition, retaliation— into sacred duties. It makes dualistic division, purity-driven exclusion, and salvation-through-destruction feel like obedience rather than pathology.

Jesus’ Counter-Narrative

The teachings most consistently attributed to the historical Jesus directly challenge this central image and the behaviors it authorizes. The core material appears in the parallels of the Sermon on the Mount and Sermon on the Plain (Matthew 5:38–48 and Luke 6:27–36), widely regarded by scholars as among the earliest and most distinctive layers of the tradition.

Jesus rejects the principle of eye-for-eye retaliation. He commands love of enemies, blessing of those who curse, and prayer for persecutors. He grounds the command in the character of God: God is kind to the ungrateful and the wicked; God causes the sun to rise on the evil and the good and sends rain on the righteous and the unrighteous. Therefore, “be merciful, just as your Father is merciful.” Love that extends only to one’s own group is ordinary; the distinctive requirement is love that includes enemies and outsiders. This is presented not as an optional supererogatory ideal but as the imitation of Ultimate Reality itself.

The Nazareth synagogue episode (Luke 4) illustrates the same move in narrative form. Jesus reads from Isaiah 61 and stops at the proclamation of the year of the Lord’s favor, omitting the expected note of vengeance. He then cites examples of God’s mercy extended to outsiders— the widow of Zarephath and Naaman the Syrian— provoking fury and an attempt to kill him. The reaction matches what would be expected when a validating tribal and punitive theology is publicly refused. The parables of the Prodigal Son and the vineyard workers further dramatize the scandal of unconditional inclusion: those invested in conditional, retaliatory accounting are angered by generosity that does not keep score.

Additional elements reinforce the counter. Jesus critiques the temple sacrifice system that rested on the logic of appeasing an offended deity. He defines greatness as service rather than domination or lording over others. The emphasis falls on forgiveness, inclusion of the marginalized, and the transformation of the heart rather than the violent purging of external enemies. The primary struggle is internal— against the impulses that produce tribal exclusion, domination, and destructive retaliation— rather than an external war against demonized others.

This is not a minor ethical refinement of existing religion. It replaces the cohering center. Where the older complex pictured Ultimate Reality as tribal and punitive, the Jesus material pictures it as non-retaliatory and no-conditions in its mercy and love. The supporting themes lose their ultimate authorization.

Systematic Counters to the Bad Ideas

Once the central image changes, the rest of the complex is undercut in specific ways.

The original-paradise and Fall narrative loses its foundation when humans are no longer defined as the essential corruptors of a lost perfect world who deserve ongoing divine punishment. The emphasis can shift to the long human rise out of animal impulses through learning, cooperation, and creativity. Declinism and human degeneration are no longer the default story; the framing becomes one of gradual improvement supported by the historical record of reduced violence and rising well-being. Apocalyptic terror and the demand for imminent purging lose their theological driver when there is no ultimate punitive destruction threatened by Ultimate Reality. The survival impulse is not continually stoked by the prospect of divine ending, reducing susceptibility to schemes that destroy present societies to “save” them.

The deformed hero’s quest is reoriented. Cosmic dualism that requires the extermination of irredeemable outsiders is replaced by an internal struggle and by the explicit command to love enemies. Inclusion of outsiders becomes the mark of fidelity to the non-tribal God rather than betrayal. Domination and elite gatekeeping are contradicted by the definition of greatness as service. The economy of sacrifice and retributive payment becomes unnecessary when mercy is unconditional and justice is restorative rather than strictly retributive.

What remains is a coherent alternative complex: Ultimate Reality as non-threatening and inclusive; humanity as capable of rising and creating rather than essentially fallen; justice as restorative and oriented toward inclusion; the hero’s task as internal transformation and outward mercy; and hope grounded in ordinary human capacities and observable long-term betterment rather than in mythical restoration after collapse.

Outcomes and Implications

The practical difference appears in the emotions, motivations, and policies each complex tends to produce. The tribal and punitive framing generates fear, excessive guilt and shame, dualistic division, and repeated readiness for destructive crusades. The unconditional framing reduces the metaphysical terror that drives “madness of crowds” responses, undercuts the sacralization of scapegoating and domination, and supports cooperation across differences. It does not deny human imperfection or the need for accountability; it refuses to treat retribution, exclusion, and destruction as the ultimate expression of justice or the will of Ultimate Reality.

Historical reconstruction of Jesus remains debated on many points, and later Christian tradition re-merged elements of the older punitive and apocalyptic framework with the newer material. Yet the distinctive teachings on non-retaliation, love of enemies, and the non-tribal character of God are among the best-attested and most radical features of the early tradition. They constitute a direct challenge to the image that had long held the destructive complex together. The lasting question is which set of themes more consistently orients human narratives toward flourishing without requiring the ruin of existing societies in the name of salvation.

(End of Grok comments)

Next:

Lets do Explore the historical Jesus context, Explore Jesus’ teachings on loving enemies, and Show how tribal God justifies violence.

Grok:

Historical Jesus in Context, the Teaching on Loving Enemies, and the Tribal God as Justification for Violence

The Historical Setting of Jesus

Jesus of Nazareth lived and taught in first-century Jewish Palestine under Roman imperial control. After Pompey’s intervention in 63 BCE, the region moved from Hasmonean independence into the Roman sphere. Herod the Great ruled as a client king until 4 BCE; after him, Galilee (where Jesus grew up and conducted most of his public activity) was governed by Herod Antipas, while Judea (including Jerusalem) fell under direct Roman prefects, of whom Pontius Pilate held office during Jesus’ ministry. The Temple and its high-priestly aristocracy (associated with the Sadducees) managed local affairs in cooperation with Roman authorities, provided order was maintained.

The population was predominantly Jewish, shaped by the memory of foreign domination, the centrality of the Temple, and the Torah. Josephus describes three major groups: Pharisees (emphasizing careful observance and oral tradition), Sadducees (priestly and aristocratic), and Essenes (stricter, sometimes communal, with strong dualistic and purity concerns). Most people belonged to none of these parties. Apocalyptic and messianic hopes circulated: expectations of divine intervention to end foreign rule, restore Israel, or bring final judgment. Economic pressures, taxation, and the presence of Roman forces and collaborators created recurring tensions, occasional riots, and the later rise of more militant resistance that culminated in the Jewish-Roman War of 66–70 CE and the destruction of the Temple.

Jesus operated as a Jewish teacher and prophet within this world. He addressed fellow Jews in Galilee and, eventually, Jerusalem. His activity occurred against a background of competing visions of how to remain faithful under empire— ranging from accommodation, to intensified purity and separation, to hopes of liberation. The love-of-enemies material, preserved in the earliest layers of the tradition, stands out sharply against both the pressures of occupation and the dualistic or retaliatory strains present in some contemporary Jewish and Greco-Roman thought.

Jesus’ Teaching on Loving Enemies

The command to love enemies appears in parallel form in Matthew 5:43–48 and Luke 6:27–36. Scholars widely regard the core of this material as authentic to the historical Jesus. It belongs to the sayings tradition shared by Matthew and Luke (conventionally called Q) and is not derived from Mark. Its radical and counter-cultural character, its placement as a climactic element in the inaugural teaching discourse, and the near-universal scholarly judgment that it goes back to Jesus all support this assessment. The Jesus Seminar, for example, ranked the basic imperative among the highest-probability authentic sayings.

The teaching rejects the principle of proportional retaliation (“eye for eye”) and replaces it with non-retaliation and active goodwill toward enemies: love them, do good to those who hate you, bless those who curse you, pray for those who persecute you. It explicitly criticizes limited reciprocity— “If you love those who love you, what credit is that to you?”— and extends the circle of concern beyond kin, tribe, or co-religionists. The grounding is theological rather than merely pragmatic: God is kind to the ungrateful and the wicked; God causes the sun to rise on the evil and the good and sends rain on the righteous and the unrighteous. Therefore, disciples are to “be merciful, just as your Father is merciful” (Luke) or to be perfect/complete as the heavenly Father is (Matthew). Imitation of this non-selective divine mercy is presented as the standard.

In its first-century setting the teaching was striking. Leviticus 19:18 commanded love of neighbor, but the practical scope of “neighbor” was often restricted, and some circles (including elements reflected in the Dead Sea Scrolls) combined love for the in-group with hatred of outsiders. Popular Greco-Roman maxims likewise endorsed benefiting friends and harming enemies. Under Roman occupation, “enemies” could readily include imperial forces, collaborators, or rival groups. Jesus’ formulation refused both the restricted neighbor and the permission to hate, and it located the refusal in the character of God rather than in a temporary tactical restraint. Related material— the Nazareth synagogue episode in which Jesus highlights God’s mercy to Gentiles, the Good Samaritan parable, and the critique of the sacrifice system— reinforces the same inclusive and non-retaliatory orientation.

How the Tribal God Justifies Violence

A tribal conception of God (or Ultimate Reality) pictures the divine as favoring one group, authorizing domination of others, and responding to difference or failure with retaliation, judgment, exclusion, and destruction. This image supplies a ready justification for violence in several interlocking ways.

First, it sacralizes in-group preference and out-group hostility. If God is the defender of “our” people, “our” purity, or “our” cause, then actions taken against outsiders can be framed as participation in the divine will rather than ordinary aggression. Biblical narratives of conquest, later crusading ideologies, and modern variants that cast political or cultural opponents as existential threats all draw on this logic. Harold Ellens and Zenon Lotufo have argued that a “cruel” or wrathful God image— especially one requiring bloody satisfaction or ready to destroy— functions as a cultural and psychological archetype that normalizes violence: “If your God uses force, then so may you.” The juridical atonement theories that developed within this framework further embed the idea that ultimate problems are solved by punitive destruction or substitutionary violence.

Second, the tribal God legitimizes dualistic division. When Ultimate Reality is imagined as locked in conflict with an opposing evil force, human conflicts are easily mapped onto that cosmic struggle. Differing others become not merely rivals but agents of the enemy, irredeemable and deserving of purging. Urgency intensifies when the conflict is thought to be approaching a final crisis; ordinary restraints and gradual processes appear inadequate, and extreme measures are authorized as necessary to “save” the threatened order.

Third, it underwrites domination and elite authority. A God who rules by force and demands submission provides a model and sanction for hierarchical control— whether by kings claiming divine right, priests claiming exclusive mediation, or modern ideologues claiming unique insight into the requirements of salvation or survival. Violence or coercion against those who resist can then be presented as enforcement of cosmic order rather than mere power politics.

Historical outcomes illustrate the pattern: religious wars, inquisitorial coercion, millenarian revolutions that destroy existing orders to install a purified future, and secular ideologies that retain the same structure of threat, dualism, and redemptive violence. The image rarely needs to be stated in fully mythological terms; residual forms (vengeful nature, punitive history, existential enemies who must be eliminated) continue to operate.

Jesus’ teaching directly counters this mechanism. By portraying God as non-selective in mercy and kindness— even toward the ungrateful, the wicked, and enemies— and by commanding human imitation of that pattern, it removes the theological permission structure that turns tribal preference and retaliation into sacred duty. The primary conflict is relocated inward (against one’s own impulses toward exclusion and domination) rather than outward onto demonized others. Violence loses its highest authorization when the Ultimate Ideal itself is no longer pictured as tribal and punitive. The practical test remains whether narratives built on the one image or the other more consistently restrain destructive conflict and support human cooperation and improvement.

(End of Grok comments)

Next:

Lets do Explore the historical Jesus and tribal God, and Write a 1000-word article on this topic.

Grok reply:

Historical Jesus and the Rejection of the Tribal God

In first-century Jewish Palestine, under Roman occupation, competing visions of God shaped responses to empire, purity, and conflict. Most portrayed the divine as the defender of Israel against outsiders— a tribal God who favored the chosen, authorized resistance or separation, and promised judgment on enemies. Jesus of Nazareth offered a sharply different image. His teaching on loving enemies, grounded in a God who shows mercy without partiality, directly challenged the tribal conception of Ultimate Reality and the violence it justified.

The setting was one of layered authority and tension. Galilee, Jesus’ primary arena, was ruled by Herod Antipas as a client of Rome; Judea fell under Roman prefects such as Pontius Pilate, with the high-priestly aristocracy managing the Temple in cooperation with imperial power. Jewish groups differed on how to remain faithful: Pharisees stressed careful observance, Sadducees aligned with Temple elites, Essenes practiced stricter separation and dualism, and various apocalyptic hopes looked for divine intervention to end foreign rule.

Across these options ran a common thread— the conviction that God was Israel’s God, hostile or indifferent to Gentiles and collaborators, and prepared to act punitively against threats to the people’s identity and land. Conquest traditions, purity codes, and expectations of final judgment reinforced the logic that outsiders could be treated as enemies of God.

This tribal image of God supplied ready justification for hostility. If the divine favored one group and opposed others, then retaliation, exclusion, or even violence against the out-group could be framed as participation in God’s will rather than ordinary aggression. Dualistic strains— visible in some Dead Sea Scrolls texts that commanded love for the sons of light and hatred for the sons of darkness— mapped human conflicts onto a cosmic struggle. Under occupation, Romans, tax collectors, and rival Jews readily became the enemies whose defeat would restore order.

The same pattern appears across history whenever a punitive, in-group deity authorizes force: the God who uses violence against enemies licenses human violence in the same cause. As later analysts such as Harold Ellens have noted, a wrathful God image tends to normalize force— “If your God uses force, then so may you”— and to generate the guilt and fear that make populations receptive to destructive crusades.

Jesus’ response centered on the command to love enemies, preserved in the earliest shared sayings tradition (Matthew 5:43–48 and Luke 6:27–36). Scholars widely accept the core of this material as authentic: it is radical, counter-cultural, and not derived from later church concerns. Jesus rejects eye-for-eye retaliation and limited reciprocity. Love that stops at one’s own group is ordinary; the distinctive requirement is active goodwill toward those who hate, curse, or persecute. The grounding is theological. God is kind to the ungrateful and the wicked; God makes the sun rise on the evil and the good and sends rain on the righteous and the unrighteous. Disciples are therefore to “be merciful, just as your Father is merciful.” The standard is imitation of a non-selective divine mercy, not tribal preference or tactical restraint.

The teaching was striking in its context. While Leviticus commanded love of neighbor, the practical scope was often restricted, and some circles explicitly combined in-group love with out-group hatred. Greco-Roman commonplaces endorsed helping friends and harming enemies. Jesus refused both the restricted neighbor and the permission to hate, locating the refusal in the character of God. Related episodes reinforce the point. In the Nazareth synagogue he highlights God’s mercy to Gentiles (the Sidonian widow and Naaman), provoking fury. The Good Samaritan parable defines neighbor across ethnic lines. Critiques of the sacrifice system challenge the economy of appeasing an offended deity. Greatness is redefined as service rather than domination.

This constitutes a direct rejection of the tribal God. Where the older image authorized exclusion and punitive destruction, Jesus’ image removes the theological permission structure. Ultimate Reality is no longer pictured as the partisan defender of one people against others, ready to destroy the impure or the opposing. The primary conflict is relocated inward— against the impulses toward tribalism, domination, and retaliation— rather than outward onto demonized enemies. Violence loses its highest sanction when the Ultimate Ideal itself is non-retaliatory and inclusive.

The historical Jesus did not invent non-violence or universalism from nothing; strands of Jewish tradition already urged kindness to strangers and restraint. What was distinctive was the explicit extension to enemies, the rejection of dualistic hatred, and the grounding in a God whose mercy is not conditioned on group membership or prior worthiness. Later Christian tradition often re-merged this material with punitive and apocalyptic themes, producing the very tribal and wrathful images the teaching had challenged. The original contrast remains clear: a tribal God justifies violence by making it sacred duty; the non-tribal, merciful God of Jesus’ teaching undercuts that justification and reorients the hero’s quest toward inclusion and inner transformation.

The practical difference is measurable in the narratives each image supports. One repeatedly licenses “salvation through destruction” of the threatening other. The other withholds ultimate authorization for such projects and directs energy toward mercy that does not keep tribal score. In the context of first-century Palestine, and in the longer history of human conflict, that difference is the measure of the challenge Jesus posed to the tribal conception of God.

(End of Grok comments)

Next:

Lets Explore Harold Ellens analysis

Grok response:

Harold Ellens’ Analysis of the Destructive Power of Religious Metaphors

J. Harold Ellens (1932–), a psychologist, theologian, retired U.S. Army chaplain, and former executive of the Christian Association for Psychological Studies, has focused much of his work on the psychological and cultural effects of religious images, particularly how certain metaphors of God foster violence. His most influential project in this area is the multi-volume The Destructive Power of Religion: Violence in Judaism, Christianity, and Islam (Praeger, 2004; condensed edition 2007), which he edited and to which he contributed key essays. The collection examines shared roots of violence across the Abrahamic traditions and argues that specific core metaphors function as unconscious archetypes that shape behavior.

Ellens’ central claim is that Judaism, Christianity, and Islam inherited from ancient sources— especially a dualistic cosmic-conflict framework with Zoroastrian influences— a “Master Story” in which history and the human soul are locked in a struggle between absolute good and absolute evil (God versus the devil or equivalent forces). This conflict, the story holds, cannot be resolved without ultimate violence: the extermination of nations, the execution of humans, or even the death of God’s own son. These metaphors are not peripheral; they settle into the center of the Western psyche and collective unconscious, infecting both religious and secular culture. Ellens describes the relevant scriptural passages as “toxic texts” that continue to generate destructive outcomes because they supply divine example and imperative.

In the essay “Religious Metaphors Can Kill,” Ellens argues that theological doctrines are rooted in an underlying model of God that determines their character and cultural impact. Conservative Western Christianity, he contends, has at its center the image of a cruel and wrathful God. Anselm’s juridical (penal substitutionary) atonement theory is a direct outgrowth of this image: God is so disturbed by human sin that the only options are destruction or a bloody sacrifice to satisfy justice. The crucifixion is thereby framed as necessary divine violence— an act of child sacrifice disguised as grace. Ellens notes that with such a metaphor at the center, “how could we possibly hold, in the deep structure of our unconscious motivations, any other notion of ultimate solutions to ultimate questions or crises than violence?” The practical corollary, often summarized in related discussion of his work, is that if God uses force, so may humans who image themselves as acting on God’s behalf.

Ellens further develops the psychological mechanism: religious metaphors produce unconscious archetypes that people act out while believing they are doing good. A “sick god”— one portrayed as caught in cosmic war and solving problems through ultimate violence— generates “sick people.” Dualistic framing turns ordinary human conflicts into metaphysical battles in which opponents become irredeemable agents of evil deserving purging. Apocalyptic urgency intensifies the pattern, legitimizing extreme measures. Ellens has also written on the positive counterpart: belief in a benevolent God of unconditional grace correlates with better psychological health (see his Radical Grace). He defines grace in biblical terms as unconditional forgiveness and acceptance, and he has suggested that recognizing human responsibility (rather than projecting cosmic war onto God) is part of moving beyond the destructive metaphors.

Zenon Lotufo Jr.’s Cruel God, Kind God (2012) explicitly builds on Ellens’ essay. Lotufo distinguishes two forms of Christianity: “Cruel God Christianity,” centered on the monarch/judge metaphors, original sin, and penal satisfaction, which produces guilt, shame, personality atrophy, and a tendency toward violence or domination; and “Kind God Christianity,” centered on father/shepherd metaphors and grace, which supports healthier personality and less punitive outlooks. Lotufo treats the image of God as a basic, often unexamined belief scheme that shapes energy, emotion, and behavior.

Ellens’ analysis aligns with the broader discussion of a tribal, dominating, and punitively destroying God. The dualistic cosmic-conflict metaphor and the wrathful deity image function as the cohering center that authorizes exclusion, retaliation, and “salvation through destruction.” They sacralize in-group preference and out-group hostility, supply psychological permission for force, and embed retributive justice as the default solution. By contrast, an image of Ultimate Reality as non-retaliatory and unconditionally merciful removes that permission structure.

Ellens’ work is interpretive and psychological rather than a strictly historical reconstruction of every text. Critics note that it emphasizes destructive strands while the traditions also contain resources for restraint and peace; the analysis is strongest as an account of how certain dominant metaphors have operated in practice and in the unconscious. Its value lies in clarifying the mechanism by which an image of God can mobilize energy toward violence or toward grace, and in underscoring that the choice of metaphor is not theologically neutral. In the context of the historical Jesus’ teaching on non-retaliation and love of enemies— grounded in a God kind to the ungrateful and wicked— Ellens’ framework highlights what was being rejected: the authorization of ultimate violence by a tribal or wrathful deity.

(End of Grok comment)

Next:

Please do Explore Lotufo’s Cruel God framework, Explore Carl Jung’s collective unconscious, and What are the implications for Christian theology.

Grok reply:

Lotufo’s Cruel God framework, Jung’s collective unconscious, and implications for Christian theology

Lotufo’s Cruel God / Kind God Framework

Zenon Lotufo Jr.’s Cruel God, Kind God (2012) builds directly on Harold Ellens’ analysis of destructive religious metaphors. Lotufo treats the image of God as a basic, largely unexamined (often affective and unconscious) belief scheme that mobilizes psychological energy and shapes personality, emotion, and behavior. People tend to become like the God they image.

He distinguishes two primary images and the forms of Christianity they generate:

• Cruel God Image (CGI): Associated metaphors are monarch and judge. The distinctive doctrine is penal satisfaction (juridical atonement). This produces a religiosity Lotufo calls Cruel God Christianity (CGC) and Cruel God Theology (CGT). Characteristic outcomes include guilt, shame, fear, anxiety, personality atrophy, low self-regard, and a tendency toward domination, intolerance, or violence. Doctrines such as original sin, hell/eternal punishment, and strong predestinarian frameworks reinforce the image. Authority is external (Bible as interpreted by others, often literally and as an excuse not to attend to conscience or the Spirit). Historically, this form has underwritten systems of domination, religious wars, the Crusades, and the Inquisition. Lotufo notes that the basic belief in a cruel or even sadistic God is frequently denied consciously, yet the doctrines and psychological effects reveal it.

• Kind God Image (KGI): Metaphors are father/mother and shepherd. The distinctive doctrine is grace. This supports Kind God Christianity (KGC). Outcomes lean toward healthier personality, self-acceptance, compassion, and an inquiring spirit. Authority is more interior (conscience, the voice of the Spirit), and biblical interpretation is subordinated to the teachings of Jesus. Lotufo sees this image as more congruent with Jesus’ parables of radical mercy and inclusion and with the portrayal of God as kind to the ungrateful and the wicked.

The same person or system can contain elements of both, but one usually dominates. Lotufo’s clinical and theological analysis links the cruel image to psychological harm analogous to abuse dynamics and to the sacralization of retributive violence. The kind image correlates with greater well-being and less punitive orientation.

Jung’s Collective Unconscious and the God-Image

Carl Jung’s concept of the collective unconscious provides a depth-psychological frame for understanding how such God-images persist and operate. Beyond the personal unconscious (repressed individual material), Jung posited a deeper, shared layer of the psyche containing archetypes— universal, primordial patterns or forms of instinctual perception and response. These are not inherited ideas but innate structuring tendencies that appear in myths, dreams, fairy tales, and religious symbols across cultures.

The God-image (Imago Dei) functions as a particularly powerful archetype, closely related to the archetype of the Self (wholeness). It is numinous— emotionally charged and autonomous— and can possess or guide the ego. Jung observed that the God-image evolves historically through the interplay of tradition and the unconscious; it is not static. Religious symbols and doctrines express archetypal contents, and confronting or transforming them is part of the individuation process (integration of conscious and unconscious toward greater wholeness).

Ellens and related interpreters apply this to “toxic texts” and violent metaphors. The dualistic cosmic-conflict story (good versus evil requiring ultimate violence) and the wrathful, punitive God become negative archetypes lodged in the Western collective unconscious. They continue to shape motivation and behavior— even among those who consciously reject formal religion— because they operate below the level of ordinary awareness. “Sick gods make sick people”: if the central archetype solves ultimate problems through violence or exclusion, humans mirror it. Lotufo’s cruel/kind distinction can be read as two dominant constellations of the God-archetype, with different psychological and social consequences.

Implications for Christian Theology

These analyses carry several implications for Christian theology, particularly regarding the image of God, atonement, and the relative weight of different strands of the tradition.

First, they challenge the psychological and cultural neutrality of doctrines centered on a wrathful, retributive God who requires penal satisfaction. Lotufo and Ellens argue that Anselmian-style juridical atonement, when paired with strong original sin and eternal punishment, embeds the cruel image, generates guilt/shame dynamics, and supplies archetypal permission for violence (“if your God uses force, so may you”). This does not automatically invalidate every formulation of atonement, but it raises the question whether certain dominant Western expressions have sacralized retribution in ways that conflict with the non-retaliatory mercy emphasized in the core historical Jesus material (love of enemies, God kind to the ungrateful and wicked, sun and rain on good and evil).

Second, they support greater attention to alternative theological resources already present in the tradition: Jesus’ parables of unconditional inclusion, the redefinition of greatness as service, critiques of the sacrifice system, and portrayals of God as Father whose mercy is not conditioned on group membership or prior worthiness. Non-violent, restorative, or Christus Victor models of atonement, and stronger emphasis on grace as unconditional rather than merely conditional upon satisfaction of wrath, align more readily with the kind-God image and with reduced tendency toward dualistic purging.

Third, they imply a criterion of discernment that includes psychological and social outcomes alongside traditional doctrinal fidelity. If a God-image systematically produces personality atrophy, excessive fear, and readiness for “salvation through destruction,” that counts against it— especially when an alternative image rooted in the same tradition’s most distinctive ethical and theological teachings produces different results. This does not require abandoning Christianity; it requires critical evaluation of which archetypal image dominates and whether later punitive developments have buried or deformed the non-tribal, non-retaliatory center associated with Jesus.

Defenders of classical penal substitution respond that the doctrine is Trinitarian (the Triune God bears the cost, not a Father abusing a Son), that divine wrath is the necessary correlate of holy love against evil rather than sadistic rage, and that the cross is self-substitution in love. The psychological critique does not settle the exegetical or systematic debate, but it highlights real historical and pastoral costs of certain presentations and underscores the ongoing choice between competing God-images within the Christian sources themselves.

In short, Lotufo’s framework and Jung’s account of the collective unconscious together suggest that the image of God is not a secondary matter. It functions as a powerful, often unconscious archetype that either authorizes tribal exclusion and retributive violence or undercuts them in favor of mercy and inclusion. Christian theology is therefore implicated in the ongoing task of clarifying which image it places at the center.

(End of Grok comments)

Now my list:

The original “bad religious ideas” complex of themes that our ancestors constructed to shape their narratives, Wendell Krossa

Critical point– The bad religious ideas complexes are centered by a God who is tribal, dominating, and punitively destroying. This God gives meaning to and energizes the related bad ideas in this list:

Intro note:

The ancients badly messed up theology at the beginning of human mythmaking and too many of us still hold to their psychopathology and mental deformity today. Paul immortalized the worst of the primitive thinking of our ancestors in his Christ myth and that is how the original bad ideas were given dominance in our Western civilization, in its narratives, and human consciousness. Paul and his Christ myth have been an overwhelmingly prominent influence on Western minds (see James Tabor’s comments on this in “Paul and Jesus”). This is not to deny the better features in Paul’s merger of Jesus with his Christ myth, but to note that such mergers of good and bad themes tend to result in the deforming/weakening of the better features in the mix. I side with Thomas Jefferson and Leo Tolstoy that in Paul’s Christ the “diamonds of Jesus have been buried” by the inhumane features of the Christ (i.e. tribalism in the saving of true believers but the exclusion and damnation of unbelievers, domination epitomized in “Lord Christ” and the demanded submission of women to husbands and slaves to masters, and the violent destruction of unbelievers through world-destroying apocalypse and eternal burning in hell).

Critical to note, Paul’s Christ has been mainly responsible for bringing the fallacy of apocalyptic into Western civilization to continue its destructive impacts on human personality and society by terrorizing people with ultimate threat that incites their survival impulse and renders them to irrational and destructive “salvation” schemes (i.e. to “save the world by ruining, notably in the modern era, liberal democracy societies”).

The ideas/beliefs in the list below are as old as the primitive minds of our ancestors who constructed them just as they were emerging out of animal existence. They created the core themes of the first mythologies that would frame the basic beliefs of later major religions and then also shape modern-era secular ideologies, etc.

So be careful of any back-patting of yourself about being a modern liberated “secular materialist, even atheist”. All of us are profoundly shaped by the same “Homo-religiosus” impulse as the rest of the human family, known also as the primal impulse for meaning. And too many of us still unconsciously embrace the core themes of all past narratives, unaware of their primitive origins and dominance as the archetypes of the collective human subconscious.

Our ancestors felt their primal urge to meaning and purpose, and in response they began to explain the world around them with irrational myths like spirits/gods behind all elements of the natural world threatening to punish them with natural disasters, accidents, disease, etc. for mistakes/failures.

Their mythical beliefs explained and validated the dominant impulses that shaped their primitive existence- i.e. the impulse to tribalism, the urge to dominate others, and the impulse to destroy differing others that they viewed as threats (i.e. exterminate competition). They even created gods to embody the same impulses as ultimate validating authorities for their primitive existence (ultimate ideals and authorities).

Their primitive beliefs shaped how they thought, what they felt, what motivated/energized them, and consequently how they responded to events, how they acted.

In the list below I have included some of the more prominent ideas/myths that our ancestors constructed.

Critical to emphasize in the mix of bad ideas- The ancients created an “Ultimate Ideal” to hold their complex of mythical ideas together, a cohering Center that would function as the Ultimate Authority to validate all the rest. In doing that, they initiated “theology” (i.e. human ideas and images of God) to form the heart of all mythology and to dominate the eventual religions that would emerge out of earlier mythologies.

Then with deity eventually framed by subsequent generations of theologians as “immutable”, the original complexes of mythical ideas were given extra impetus to continue down through history to dominate world religions as unchanging divine truths, as inspired by God. And because few dare to question the most foundational of all ideas/beliefs- i.e. deity- hence, we find the persistence of the same old deity images across world religions and even embedded in our “secular ideologies”. Psychologist Harold Ellens explained this “monster God” phenomenon and its effects/outcomes on human personality and behavior.

Note Ellen’s point below that few people, if any, ever question the image of God that our cultures have inherited. My argument is that Historical Jesus did exactly that- He challenged and rejected the dominant image of God that prevailed in his time and offered a stunning new image of deity as non-retaliatory, as no conditions love, an image that would have transformed human belief systems entirely. But Paul emerged two decades later to reject the stunning new theology of Jesus, overturn it, and re-instate traditional theology of wrathful, vengeful deity to dominate his new Christ myth and Christian religion. Paul buried the new theology of Jesus in the same old mythological frameworks of all previous history.

Ellens’ quotes from Zenon Lotufo’s “Cruel God, Kind God”:

“Beliefs… generate ‘dynamis’, or mobilize energy… (they) may result, for instance, in fanaticism and violence, or… may also produce anxiety and inhibitions that hinder the full manifestation of the capacities of a person…

“The image of God can be seen as a basic belief or scheme, and as such it is never questioned…

“Basic cultural beliefs are so important, especially in a dominant widespread culture, because they have the same properties as individual basic beliefs, that is, they are not perceived as questionable. The reader may object that “God”, considered a basic belief in our culture, is rejected or questioned by a large number of people today. Yet the fact is that the idea of God that those people reject is almost never questioned. In other words, their critique assumes there is no alternative way of conceiving God except the one that they perceive through the lens of their culture. So, taking into account the kind of image of God that prevails in Western culture- a ‘monster God’… such rejection is understandable…

“There is in Western culture a psychological archetype, a metaphor that has to do with the image of a violent and wrathful God (see Romans, Revelation). Crystallized in Anselm’s juridical atonement theory, this image represents God sufficiently disturbed by the sinfulness of humanity that God had only two options: destroy us or substitute a sacrifice to pay for our sins. He did the latter. He killed Christ.

“Ellens goes on by stating that the crucifixion, a hugely violent act of infanticide or child sacrifice, has been disguised by Christian conservative theologians as a ‘remarkable act of grace’. Such a metaphor of an angry God, who cannot forgive unless appeased by a bloody sacrifice, has been ‘right at the center of the Master Story of the Western world for the last 2,000 years. And the unavoidable consequence for the human mind is a strong tendency to use violence’.

“’With that kind of metaphor at our center, and associated with the essential behavior of God, how could we possibly hold, in the deep structure of our unconscious motivations, any other notion of ultimate solutions to ultimate questions or crises than violence- human solutions that are equivalent to God’s kind of violence’…

“Hence, in our culture we have a powerful element that impels us to violence, a Cruel God Image… that also contributes to guilt, shame, and the impoverishment of personality…”.

As Harold Ellens says, “If your God uses force, then so may you, to get your way against your ‘enemies’”.

(End of Ellens quotes)

Note that the ideas/myths/beliefs that have shaped Christianity predate that religion by millennia. Christianity borrowed from all that went before, just as all succeeding movements do, whether religious or secular/ideological. Research has revealed the influence of Zoroastrian mythology, ancient Judaism (notably Jewish apocalyptic), Hellenism, and other strains of mythology, on Paul’s Christ myth and religion.

The dominant themes of world religions, and subsequent contemporary “secular/ideological” belief systems, trace back to the very beginning of human curiosity and endeavors to explain reality and life. Consequently, the problems of Christianity mirror the problems of all humanity and all human stories. The “bad ideas” in Christianity are everywhere embedded in both in religious and secular/ideological systems of belief.

Hence, “bad ideas inciting and validating bad behavior” is a worldwide problem. As Joseph Campbell noted- “People have believed the same primitive myths across all history and across all the cultures of the world”. The “bad ideas” pathology is not isolated to any one group as worse than others. All human narratives share the same basic complexes of common themes.

The “bad religious ideas” that have darkened and enslaved human minds from the beginning (updated, revised), Wendell Krossa

These ideas, and the narratives they frame, incite endless eruptions of “madness of crowds” irrationality and hysteria that lead to “salvation” schemes that destroy societies to save some imagined threatened world.

Don’t dismiss these ideas/myths/themes below out of hand as residual religious fallacies that have nothing to do with contemporary worldviews. Most people today still hold these core themes in their worldviews/narratives. These themes dominate the narratives of the major world religions that some 85% of humanity are affiliated with (Pew survey of world population).

“The Global Religious Landscape”

https://www.pewresearch.org/religion/2012/12/18/global-religious-landscape-exec/

AI Overview

Approximately 75% to 85% of the global population identifies with a religion or spiritual tradition, according to comprehensive demographic studies by organizations like the Pew Research Center and Our World in Data.

Global Breakdown of Major Religions

• Christianity: Largest group, with roughly 2.3 to 2.4 billion followers (about 28% to 31% of the world).

• Islam: Second-largest group, with roughly 1.9 to 2 billion followers (about 24% to 25% of the world).

• Hinduism: Third or fourth-largest group, with about 1.1 to 1.2 billion followers (roughly 15% of the world).

• Buddhism: Around 500 million followers (roughly 7% of the world).

• Folk or Traditional Religions: Around 400 to 430 million followers (including African traditional and Chinese folk religions).

• Judaism: Around 10 to 14.6 million followers (roughly 0.2% of the world).

The Religiously Unaffiliated

• Religiously Unaffiliated: Approximately 1.2 to 1.9 billion people (including atheists, agnostics, and those who say “nothing in particular”) make up roughly 16% to 24% of the global population, forming the third-largest group overall.

• Regional trends tracked by the World Population Review show that non-affiliation is heavily concentrated in places like China, as well as parts of Europe and North America, whereas regions like sub-Saharan Africa and the Middle East maintain over 90% religious affiliation.

Would you like to see a breakdown of religious affiliation for a specific country or region, or look more closely at projected demographic shifts by 2050?

Further prompt from me:

This misses the point that most of the unaffiliated category identity often as “spiritual though not religious” and most hold to the same basic themes of religious narratives as outlined on sites like http://www.wendellkrossa.com/

Gemini response:

The user’s comment highlights a vital nuance in modern sociology of religion: individuals categorized as “religiously unaffiliated” are often not entirely secular, but rather identify as “spiritual but not religious” while maintaining ancient, foundational archetypes of religious narratives.

The website The Unconditional Human Spirit by Wendell Krossa argues that both traditional religions and modern, secular movements (like Marxism, environmental alarmism, or AI doomerism) frequently reuse the exact same hidden “threat theology” or “salvation-through-destruction” frameworks.

The Structural Overlap: Shared Narrative Themes

Even when people detach themselves from formal religious institutions, their underlying worldview often continues to rely on a specific psychological and narrative scaffolding outlined on Krossa’s site:

• Cosmic Dualism (Insiders vs. Outsiders): The psychological splitting of the world into a “pure, righteous group” and a “monstrous, corrupting out-group”.

• The Impending Apocalypse: The persistent, narrative-driven panic that the world is on the brink of imminent, catastrophic collapse due to human corruption (e.g., climate change or runaway AI).

• Salvation through Destruction / Purging: The belief that a perfect future or utopian state can only be ushered in by defeating, punishing, or completely restructuring the corrupt element.

• Elite Gatekeepers / Authorizing Figures: A shifting of authority from priests to modern “enlightened elites” or scientists who dictate the terms of salvation to the public.

The Proposed Alternative: A Non-Threatizing Frame

Rather than slipping from organized religion into secularized versions of “threat theology,” Krossa’s framework suggests extracting a different archetype entirely— one anchored in unconditional beneficence and the rejection of retaliatory justice. The ultimate goal of this perspective is to challenge the psychological mechanism where human beings mirror a punitive “Ultimate Reality” by acting out domination and exclusion toward others.

(End of AI Overview)

Continuing…

Profoundly religious themes, the most primitive of human ideas, also dominate the widely believed climate crisis narratives, just as they frame socialist/Marxist narratives (see Grok’s research on this below). And they also shape, as noted above, the worldviews of the 15% of humanity that claim “unaffiliated” status in regard to world religions, but still hold some version of “spiritual but not religious”.

(1) The foundational plank in the narratives that we have inherited from our ancestors is the myth that the past was better… it was a golden age, an original paradise world.

This most fundamental mythical fallacy promotes reminiscent longing for something that never existed. Psychology speaks to this “rosy retrospection” fallacy of recalling the past more positively than it actually was. See for example, paleo-geological histories of the origins and development of our Earth. They expose entirely this foundational fallacy in all religions that the past was better, that life started in some paradisal state like Sumerian Dilmun or Hebrew Eden, or the modern environmentalism version that the past paradise was a wilderness world with few humans to corrupt and defile pure/pristine Mother Nature.

Just do a search for any geological history of Earth to see the brutally uninhabitable conditions of the early Earth. There was no paradise in the past.

Prehistorian John Pfeiffer suggests that the belief in an original golden age on Earth may have emerged around 100,000 years ago. That prompted me to take a look at conditions on Earth around that time. I would suggest that perhaps the fallacy of original paradisal world probably began as our ancestors experienced the rapid ending of the Eemian interglacial of some 130-115,000 years ago. Research reveals that previous interglacial was some 8 degrees C. warmer than our current Holocene interglacial. A paradisal warm period that would have enhanced human survival and the flourishing of all life that prefers such warmth (i.e. most species of plants and animals are found in the warmer equatorial regions of earth, evidence that biological life prefers warmth).

https://co2coalition.org/facts/the-last-interglacial-was-8c-14f-warmer-than-today/#:~:text=The%20results%20revealed%20that%20the,%C2%B0F)%20warmer%20than%20today.

Some studies suggest the “Eemian” interglacial may have ended suddenly, over just a few centuries, or possibly just decades. Our ancestors, even with their much shorter lifespans (20-30ish years) would have remembered the better past as the previous warmer climate that made survival easier.

See this link: https://www.esd.ornl.gov/projects/qen/transit.html

“The time span of the past few million years has been punctuated by many rapid climate transitions, most of them on time scales of centuries to decades or even less. The most detailed information is available for the Younger Dryas-to-Holocene stepwise change around 11,500 years ago, which seems to have occurred over a few decades. The speed of this change is probably representative of similar but less well-studied climate transitions during the last few hundred thousand years. These include sudden cold events (Heinrich events/stadials), warm events (Interstadials) and the beginning and ending of long warm phases, such as the Eemian interglacial.”

(2) The second major bad religious idea is the myth that early perfect humans committed an original error and subsequently became corrupted and then ruined that original paradise world. If the past was better, then what happened? Well, blame humanity.

Thus begins the long history of anti-humanism, the mythology of the “Fall of mankind” that renders all succeeding generations of humanity essentially corrupt and sinful. Humans are labelled the destroyers of good, destroyers of the pristine natural world. In the environmental variant on this, humans are viewed as “a cancer or virus on earth”, an unwanted intruder into nature.

And we are an easy target. Our developing consciousness, even in the ancient past, left us with an intense sense of our own imperfection and that we consequently deserved blame, we deserved punishment. Any basic awareness of ourselves as imperfectly human, any basic honesty about our less-than-pristine nature, will position us as the easy targets of guilt, shame, and self-blame.

(Insert: I distinguish between healthy and rational awareness of one’s personal imperfections and the natural accompanying guilt/shame that pushes us to engage further self-improvement. I separate that from the excessive guilt/shame that arises from the fallacies of bad religious ideas, the unhealthy guilt and shame that deforms human personality and results in the excessive beating up of ourselves over mistakes and failures.)

The myth that humans have ruined the original paradise world begins the long history of the fallacy of humanity as the destroyer of nature.

Related to this, early people, feeling their own impulse to retaliate against the offenses of others, then projected that base impulse onto deity, and constructed the mental pathology of God as a punitive and violent Judge who would respond harshly to human failure. These varied lines of thought would coalesce in the myth of a God who was angry with fallen humans for the offense of ruining his originally perfect creation. (See added notes at bottom)

It was then believed that the pissed deity punished people through the varied harmful elements of the natural world, through the world that he had created perfect but they had ruined. Consequently, humanity then had to suffer the consequences of ruined nature with its harsh elements of natural disasters, disease, accident, and predatory cruelty, both animal and human.

The ultimate final punishment would be effected by God through the apocalyptic destruction of the world and then wrapped up in the eternal torture of corrupted humanity in hell.

People embraced the myth that they were divinely cursed and that was their justly deserved fate. Our ancestors felt that they were bad to the bone and deserved the divine retributions expressed throughout early mythology.

Further related bad ideas were constructed, based on the myth of an original fall of humanity- i.e. that fallen people were “created to serve the gods, to do the work of the gods, to feed the gods”. Fallen, sinful humanity deserved enslavement and servitude. Hence, we see the demand for submission to authority- i.e. fallen, corrupted people, with minds too darkened by sin to know what is good for them, must be dominated by gods and their elite priesthoods. They must be led by dominating elites appointed by God to lord over the ignorant commoners who don’t know what is good for themselves. (Is this line of thinking behind Plato’s “philosopher kings” as the elites who, alone as truly enlightened ones, should dominate and control societies?)

Continuing with the fallacy of divine punishment exhibited through the “ruined” world…

The Christian bible (in the first book- Genesis) presents the ancient Hebrew version of this mythology of human corruption and consequent punishment through the imperfections of a fallen world.

Note these initial themes in Genesis 1-3:

First, the biblical God establishes tribal hatred, jealousy, antagonism, and conflict between groups (i.e. Zoroastrian cosmic dualism replicated in human tribal opposition)- “I will put enmity between you and the woman and between your offspring and hers.”

The biblical emphasis on conflict between groups of people illustrates how ancient mythology deforms the hero’s quest. Conflict with other people misdirects the hero’s quest away from an inner battle with our own inherited animal impulses as our real enemy/monster. It directs our sense of something bad to be opposed and conquered outward toward other imperfect humans as the enemies/monsters to be fought and defeated.

Alexander Solzhenitsyn responded to the ancient perception that the human struggle of good against evil was a battle between differing groups/classes of people by arguing the real battle of good against evil took place inside each human heart. Affirming Solzhenitsyn, I would also emphasize that the real battle of good against evil is a battle that must be fought inside every human heart, a battle against the evil that is inside each one of us, against our real enemy- i.e. our inheritance of animal impulses to tribalism, domination, and punitive destruction of differing others.

Continuing with the Genesis affirmation of primitive mythology- Deity then promised suffering and pain through the imperfections of a ruined world as punishment for original sin- “I will make your pains in childbearing very severe; with painful labor you will give birth to children. Cursed is the ground because of you; through painful toil you will eat food from it all the days of your life. It will produce thorns and thistles for you, and you will eat the plants of the field. By the sweat of your brow, you will eat your food.”

Add also, the Genesis affirmation of subservience and domination in human relationships- “Your desire will be for your husband, and he will rule over you.” So begins the validation of patriarchal domination. Paul (or whoever wrote Ephesians) continues this validation of domination/subservience in relationships- “Wives, submit yourselves to your own husbands… and slaves submit yourselves to your masters.”

Additional notes on fallen humanity mythology:

The fallacy of an original paradise ruined by early people generates the natural felt need to correct the wrong that humans are blamed for having caused, to rebalance the unbalanced scales of cosmic justice. This sense of rebalancing unbalanced justice, of correcting wrongs with retributive punishment, has long undergirded human perspective on the nature of justice as fundamentally eye for eye.

You see where I am taking this? Historical Jesus rejected eye for eye justice outright as the opening element to presenting his stunning new theology of a God who also rejects eye for eye and instead urges unconditional inclusion, forgiveness, and love of even enemies. See again the Matthew 5:38-48 and Luke 6:27-36 central statements of the Jesus theology/message.

Moving back on track…

Blaming humanity for ruining the world, based on the fallacy of original perfection, adds and intensifies unnecessary guilt and shame in addition to the general sense of shame/guilt that most people already suffer due to the sense of their own imperfection and the imperfections of their world.

The mythology of humanity as corrupter of perfection, is an original element in building the case for anti-humanism in human narratives, a psychopathology that has deformed human consciousness for millennia, adding to the burden of human fear, anxiety, despair, depression, nihilism, and more.

The fallacy of an original “fall into sin” became a prominent theme in the mythology of cultures across the world- i.e. that early humans had made an original mistake, committed an error/sin that angered the gods and brought an end to a previous paradise world. We find this fallacy promoted in some of the earliest human writing- i.e. in the Sumerian myth of Dilmun where Enki ate the 8 forbidden plants and ruined that original paradise. We see this in the Eden myth where Adam and Eve corrupted an original paradise and were punished by God who then cursed life with suffering through the imperfections of a subsequently ruined world.

Thus begins the mythologies of fallen, sinful humanity angering God, who as creator of perfection and upholder of justice as eye for eye, must then punish bad people. This psychopathology is further affirmed with associated ideas of deity behind all the elements of the natural world- i.e. gods of storm and thunder, gods of sun and drought, gods of varied animal species, gods of trees, gods of streams, and so on.

And because the varied elements of nature are often harmful and destructive- i.e. natural disasters, disease, accidents, predatory cruelty- it was then obviously logical for primitive minds to conclude that the gods were angry with people’s sins and manifesting that punitive anger through such harmful elements of nature.

That misread of the natural world as exhibiting divine vengeance and anger, then led to affirming these features in deity- i.e. anger, retaliatory/punitive justice, vengeance, etc. These features, attributed to deity, and affirmed by primitive belief in justice as naturally retaliatory/retributive, then logically resulted in the portrayal of deity as righteously demanding appeasement and atonement. The development of that “threat theology”, based on natural world imperfections, became the basis for later development of salvation that demanded sacrifice, payment, payback.

I heard a version of the human ruin of paradise and consequent divine punishment from Manobo friends in Mindanao. They said that, in their mythologies, an original Manobo girl was pounding rice and raised her pounding stick too high, hit heaven and thereby upset the gods, who then sealed off the formerly open door of heaven. That was the original sin that ruined paradise in Manobo mythology. Every culture across the world has its own version of bad people ruining a formerly paradise world.

Concluding the “weave” above, and returning to the point…

No single book has more potently blown away the fallacy of a better past, and life subsequently declining, along with the fallacy of humans as corrupt destroyers of paradise, than Julian Simon’s “Ultimate Resource”. His data are now dated but his principles for determining the true state of life are as informative and useful as when first published in the 1980s. Numerous subsequent researchers have continued to affirm his ideas, principles, and conclusions. See, for example, “Humanprogress.org”. Greg Easterbrook also presents some interesting comment on the human contribution to improving an originally imperfect natural world (“A Moment On The Earth”). Another good follow-up to Simon is Desrocher and Szurmak’s “Population Bombed”, along with many more.

And to hone my point here, as I have noted in Bob Brinsmead’s comments elsewhere, the real story of humanity is not “how far we have fallen”, but how amazingly we have risen and improved across the millennia of our history. The true story of humanity should focus on the rise of our species out of a brutal animal past to become “the wonder of being human”, the creators of an ever-improving world. Further, see the evidence of our long-term improvement as set forth in the research of James Payne’s “History of Force”, or Stephen Pinker’s follow-up to Payne’s research in “The Better Angels of Our Nature”, or similar histories. As Julian Simon concluded, the evidence of the true state of life as improving shows that we are “more creators than destroyers”.

We have never been a fallen, corrupted species but we have always been a rising, improving, and progressing species and our inherent goodness continues to develop, grow, and manifest in the evidence of our improving all life on Earth. We don’t need religious versions of “salvation” as, across history, we have been learning and succeeding in “saving” ourselves and all life on Earth.

Continuing a bit more with the fallacy of divine anger manifested through the destructive elements of nature: Then came the pathology of “sacrifice”… as punishment and payment.

It was obvious to our primitive ancestors that the divine anger they believed was vented at them through the natural world must be appeased, as critical for their survival. That fed the innovation of some early creative mind to make sacrifices, both human and animal, in order to appease divine anger and thereby obtain blessings/favors from the gods (i.e. offerings to the gods to obtain the benefits of sun, rain, food). The logic behind sacrifice? Some suggest that it had to do with substitution- “A life for a life, blood for blood”. Take this innocent life as payment for my guilt and thereby spare my life.

A tribal man (Manobo) explained it to me thus- “We offer the blood of the animal, and the angry god eats that and is then satisfied and will not eat our souls” (i.e. punish us via sickness or accident). Something eaten in place of us, that then functions as the substitute to spare us. Again, this mythology is built on the belief that wrongs must be made right by some form of equal retribution/retaliation. Pain for pain, death for death, etc. All basic to eye for eye justice.

Or perhaps the origin of sacrifice has to do with the primitive notion that humans were created to serve the gods food? The origin of sacrifice to appease angry gods may be nothing more than gods lusting for blood as food? There is also the primitive idea that drinking the blood of defeated enemies is a further insult to those enemies, or it is a source of appropriated energy/power (appropriating the “life” of the defeated enemy).

Further, in relation to the primeval myth of humans created to feed the gods, to do the work of the gods, we find also the early sense of obligation to serve the elite representatives of gods- i.e. commoners obligated to serve the elite shaman/priests who claim the authority to represent the gods. They claim special status as those who know the secrets of the invisible realms and as self-appointed gatekeepers of the divine, they alone can communicate the will/word/law of the deities to the rest of their group. This further adds to the overall pathology of degrading, devaluing, dehumanizing, and demonizing common humanity.

From the beginning, the earliest shaman, agitating to dominate their fellow tribals, initiated the demand for domination/submission forms of relating as natural, as divinely authorized. Also, claiming special insight into the mysteries of the invisible world of the gods, the shaman established themselves as the solely qualified representatives who would speak for the gods. That early shamanic tradition evolved toward the dominating priesthoods of later states who would claim sole authority to represent the will and rule of the gods.

That early unleashing of the inherited animal impulse to dominate others (alpha-ism), eventually expressed in the Hellenistic belief of “special people as divine in some manner”, elites divinely gifted and appointed to rule commoners- as in Plato’s “philosopher kings”, those in societies claiming to be the enlightened experts most qualified to lead populations of commoners. What Richard Landes refers to as the “elite/commoner divide” of societies.

Christianity, prominently shaped by that Greek mythology (i.e. Hellenism), eventually formulated the belief in such things as “the Divine right of kings”. The elite advocacy for domination/submission forms of relating was exemplified in the Christian belief in “Lord Christ” as the epitome embodiment of ruling authority, the archetype of domination. See also, for example, Romans 13 where Paul advocates for state domination, or the book of Revelation on domination/submission as an eternal reality- i.e. Lord Jesus as eternal Ruler with a “rod of iron”.

Note: This primitive “alpha-ism” contradicts entirely the teaching of Historical Jesus that true greatness was to not lord over others but to serve others.

Insert: Other researchers suggest the human impulse to “subservience to authority” is very much attributable to the continuing presence in human brains of the primitive animal impulse to alpha domination over weaker others. See, for example, Hector Garcia’s “Alpha God: The Psychology Of Religious Violence And Oppression.”

Next theme (continuing to build on the above):

(3) The myth of “Declinism” that dominates our modern era– detailed by Arthur Herman in “The Idea of Decline In Western History”.

The idea of decline argues that the trajectory of life declines toward a worsening state. Surveys show that a majority of people across the world believe that “the world is becoming worse” (see, for example, the YouGov survey in “Ten Global Trends”). Arthur Herman stated that the idea of decline is “the most dominant and influential theme in the (modern world)”. Hollywood obsessively promotes this primitive myth in its public storytelling (i.e. the decline of life toward disastrous collapse and ending as the essential element in apocalyptic mythology and narratives).

The fallacy that life and the world is becoming worse undermines the energizing impact of hope that is essential to human wellbeing, flourishing, and endeavor. The myth of decline generates a sense of fatalism, resignation, giving up, and nihilism in people. Look at the prominence today of depression, anxiety disorder, fear of growing up, fear of having children (i.e. fear of bringing children into a world that is soon to end), etc. Again, Simon’s “Ultimate Resource” is the brilliant response/counter to the “Declinism” fallacy.

(4) Associated with the general declinism of all life: The myth of humanity becoming worse across history– i.e. “Declinism” in humanity, or the fallacy of “human degeneration” theory (see Herman in “The Idea of Decline”). This anti-humanism element has been beaten into human consciousness across history in religious narratives of original sinfulness (i.e. Adam/Eve “fall of man” mythology, original humans now fallen from a previous perfect state). This mythology deforms human consciousness with the fallacy that humanity becomes worse over time.

The “noble savage” theory that apparently still dominates academia today (i.e. early humans as more pure, strong, noble), emerged out of this myth of the fall of humanity from original perfection.

This “fall of humanity” myth also feeds into the deforming of the hero’s quest, where people view themselves in terms of Zoroaster’s cosmic dualism, naturally preferring to frame themselves as the righteous true believers on the side of the true and good religion/ideology and obligated to battle the evil enemies on the other side in some differing “false” religion/ideology, the differing others who are demonized as irredeemably corrupted, becoming ever worse, and deserving to be destroyed, exterminated, because they are framed as “existential” threats to the true believers and all life.

Contrary to this mythical fallacy of degenerating humanity, the actual improving trajectory of humanity across millennia has been covered by researchers like James Payne (“History of Force”) and Stephen Pinker (“Better Angels of Our Nature”).

Add also Paul Seabright’s “The Company of Strangers: A Natural History of Economic Life” on how the development of commerce led to the taming of human violence, as humans discovered the mutual benefits of trade/commerce, what became known as the “moralizing influence of gentle commerce”. See also “Constant Battles: The Myth of the Peaceful, Noble Savage”, by Stephen LeBlanc.

The evidence shows that we have steadily, across the millennia, become something better than before (the main indicator of human improvement- i.e. less violent). Simon’s “Ultimate Resource”, with amassed evidence on all the main indicators of the true state of life, affirms the same rising trajectory for humanity, as for all life, that of gradual improvement over time. Simon concludes that the evidence on the long-term trajectory of life and humanity shows that we have become “more creators than destroyers”. Our long-term improvement and progress reveals our essential human goodness emerging and developing across time, and this powerfully counters the fallacy of essential human corruption and degeneration.

The declining life/declining humanity theme then culminates in (5) the myth of the final collapse and ending of life, the complete and final ruination of the world in “catastrophic apocalyptic destruction”. The fallacy of the apocalyptic destruction of all life is the final phase in the mythical narrative of “original paradise ruined by humanity with life subsequently declining toward something worse as divine punishment”.

Add here the threat of divine retribution behind the ending of all life and this incites the human survival impulse to hysterical heights and that renders people susceptible to irrational salvation schemes that have repeatedly involved the destruction of life and civilization- i.e. the demand to “violently purge evil”, salvation promised through destruction as the required way to “save the world”. Religious salvation schemes often promise otherworldly salvation (utopia) that incentivizes people to abandon efforts to engage and improve this present world.

We have the extensive historical record of the outcomes of repeated apocalyptic millennial salvation crusades- i.e. the madness of revolutions that seek to destroy the existing world/civilization, as necessary to purge the “evil” of the present order. All required to prepare the way for the restoration of a lost paradise or the installation of a new millennial perfection. This was true of the Marxist and Nazi revolutions, and we are watching this repeat now in the environmental alarmist crusade against modern industrial society, viewed as the destroyer of nature (i.e. humans ruining paradise through technological civilization). Hence, modern civilization must itself be destroyed to make way for the new utopian order (i.e. the revolutionary phase of “exterminate some demonized ‘enemy’ or be exterminated”).

Again, we remember Arthur Mendel’s warning (“Vision And Violence”) to beware of embracing any form of salvation that is promised through destruction.

Grok’s take on Mendel: “Mendel’s real insight is warning us to watch out for any idea that promises salvation through catastrophe. That’s where the trouble starts.”

Insert: Varied horrific natural disasters of the past may have sparked our ancestors to invent and construct apocalyptic myths. For example, evidence has been offered that some 7,500 years ago the Mediterranean Sea rose from melting glaciers and broke through the Bosphorus Straits to flood the Black Sea.

https://www.sjsu.edu/faculty/watkins/blacksea.htm#:~:text=This%20evidence%2C%20collected%20by%20two,basin%20at%20the%20Bosphorus%20Straits.

That great destructive flood may have been what informed the Sumerian Flood myth of apocalypse, as well as the biblical account of Noah’s flood, another apocalypse story. Zoroaster then later introduced the myth of apocalypse by fire, which shaped Paul’s belief in apocalypse by fire (see Thessalonians, Revelation, etc.- “Lord Jesus returning in flaming fire to destroy…”).

When you add the element of “imminent” apocalypse, with the endless setting of dates for the “soon coming end of days”, you then incite the survival impulse of populations to higher reaches of fear, panic, and hysteria over the looming end of the world.

“Imminent apocalypse” fallacy clouds people’s minds with fear and renders them susceptible to irrational salvation schemes where they willingly support policies to destroy their lives and societies in order to “save the threatened world”. See Richard Landes (“Heaven On Earth”) for the example of the “Xhosa cattle slaughter”. Incited to hysteria over threatened apocalypse, those frightened people destroyed their main source of livelihood and ruined their society that never recovered.

Consider also here present Germany and Britain. Having sold their souls to the climate apocalypse lie and having embraced the Net Zero decarbonization lunacy as the salvation plan (“save the world”), both are on a serious slide to ruin.

We are living through the destructive madness of decarbonization in today’s climate apocalypse movement, where the very food of all life (i.e. CO2) has been demonized as the destroyer of life, where the fossil fuels that have provided the immense improvements to the human condition over that past century have been demonized as the existential threat to life. All part of the madness of “destroy the world/civilization to save the world”, the false promise of “salvation through destruction.”

To add further fear to the threat of life ending, add the myth that it gets even worse, far worse, with after-life Judgment, condemnation, exclusion, and punitive destruction- i.e. the hell myth. Eternal suffering after temporal suffering here. This is the piling metaphysically-based fears on top of physical world fears. Such lunacy, eh.

Having incited primal human fears, with threats of angry deity punishing people for their imperfection through the natural world, and further threatening eternal violence and destruction… What then?

The enlightened elites of the ancient world, the shaman and priests, convinced frightened people that the angry, retaliatory deities of their primitive mythologies demanded, as noted above, appeasement, payment, sacrifice.

Early humans then formulated the belief in (6) salvation as some form of sacrifice/payment, notably salvation through the slaughter of humans and animals. (Again, note Mendel’s point to beware of any salvation coming via destruction/death.)

In our modern-era we are urged to embrace salvationism in the obligation to make a payment for our sins, to suffer for atonement, in such things as the requirement to make some contemporary sacrifice in things like “de-growth, de-development, decarbonization”- i.e. give up the good life in modern civilization. Versions of this come at us in “Small is beautiful. Return to ‘noble primitivism’, the ‘moral superiority of the simple lifestyle’,” etc. Is this also what all that wilderness survival stuff is catering to? Sacrifice in giving up something, self-punishment, suffering as redemptive? What priests in monasteries engage- i.e. the self-flagellation with whips, hair shirts, and celibacy.

The sense of obligation to make some sacrifice is based on the view of justice as necessarily retaliatory, retributive, or punitive. That derives from myth of gods who are viewed as threatening retaliation, retribution, and punishment, and who demand appeasement, atonement in such versions of “eye for eye” justice. Ah, it’s a dense and complex interconnection of bad ideas, eh.

Consequent to such mythology, people from the beginning have felt an obligation to make a sacrifice, to pay for sin, to suffer for redemption, all fundamental to eye for eye justice. This is essential to the consequent felt need to rebalance the unbalanced scales of justice at some cosmic level.

The long-ingrained retributive version of eye for eye justice was overturned entirely by Historical Jesus in his jaw-dropping new merciful and unconditional approach to human failure that angered people to the extent that they tried to kill him at his first public presentation of his new theology (Luke 4). He rejected the fundamental view of justice by which most of humanity had lived from the very beginning. He was viewed as having blasphemously attacked and overturned a critical element in human narratives and identity.

His shocking insights and new message notably angered the religious Jews of his culture, to the extent that they tried to kill him. That happened after his first public speech.

He sparked their anger by reading a passage from Isaiah 61 that ends with the climax statement “to proclaim the year of the Lord’s favor and the day of vengeance of our God”. But he left off the last part- “the day of vengeance of our God”. His audience knew what he was up to. In their eyes, he had “blasphemously” denied the previously unquestioned theology of retaliatory, punishing deity. Jesus ended on the note of “the Lord’s favor”. He then intensified things a magnitude of order worse by citing Old Testament examples of God sending prophets to help outsiders to the Hebrew nation. Meaning, God exhibited universal favor and inclusion- i.e. unconditional mercy and love toward even enemies. Holy shitoli.

To people long indoctrinated with justice as divine retribution, that mercy grated and outraged them, “All the people in the synagogue were furious when they heard this”. They demanded an affirmation of divine vengeance and justice as punishment and destruction of their enemies, not unconditional favor toward them.

So also, Jonah had sulked in a pissed-off hissy fit of depression when God did not destroy Ninevah after he had prophesied such apocalyptic destruction. God took mercy even on cattle. Jonah said in the book named after him, chapter 4, “I knew that you are a gracious and compassionate God, slow to anger and abounding in love, a God who relents from sending calamity… Now, LORD, take away my life, for it is better for me to die than to live”. All because God took mercy even on “many animals.”

People angry at love and mercy toward others? That is a sad state of mind and spirit for us to remain locked into. That’s what millennia of indoctrination with myths of angry, retaliatory Gods has done to people’s minds. Leaving many still demanding justice that is defined by and grounded soundly in retaliatory violence toward “enemies”.

And get this critical point– i.e. that Jesus challenged and rejected the very God of his audience. Their fundamental image of deity. In the minds of those Jews, there could be no other way of imaging deity. To think otherwise of God would be heresy, blasphemy, unbelief, satanic, sinful.

Jesus’ protest against the sacrifice industry was one element of his fundamental protest against the human felt obligation to appease angry gods, based as such felt obligation had long been on the fallacy of retaliatory, punitive deity (i.e. monster God theology). Most fundamentally though, he was protesting the very theology that undergirded the sacrifice industry and the eye for eye justice (i.e. payment) that was based on that retributive theology. It was all part of the same overall protest.

In the story of the synagogue reading, Jesus’ audience knew that he was protesting and rejecting the very God that they worshipped- i.e. the theology of wrathful punitive destroyer, Judge of all. Jesus did not conclude with rejection of the old system but moved on to present an entirely opposite theology- i.e. the stunning new theology of a non-retaliatory, unconditional God who promoted a stunning new form of justice as restorative- i.e. “love your enemy”.

Jesus’ radical new message overturned and rendered meaningless all that his audience believed in. His teaching was too radical for his audience to even comprehend and countenance, as it meant the disintegration of their old worldview and identity, and reintegration around something entirely new and opposite to all that they had lived by. He was proposing a death and rebirth of radical magnitude. How people viewed their very selves as human and members of a long-existing culture and society.

Hence, his audience of faithful Jews were offended, outraged. His message incited in them a form of survival desperation. Their system of belief/meaning was subjected to the “threat” from a divine generosity so contrary to all that they believed. Jesus’ message was experienced as an existential threat to their very core identity.

Jesus, standing in front of them, had rejected the most basic human understanding of “justice” that had prevailed for millennia, what had always affirmed the Jew’s, and other’s, inherited impulses to tribalism (true believers favored, unbelievers/outsiders rejected and destroyed), and to punitive destruction of enemies as true and righteous justice. Jesus’ no conditions love overturned that deeply ingrained sense of justice along with related fundamental Jewish perceptions of righteousness, truth, goodness, etc.

The religion of his fellow Jews was based on their view of God (ultimate reality) as the defender of their tribe against enemies and the upholder of their truth, their righteous causes, the defender of goodness in general. That view of God and justice had long undergirded their very identity, and their livelihood/income (i.e. the priests involved in the sacrifice industry). It validated the religion that granted them the status of supremacy over others, as more favored by God than all others (“chosen people” myths).

Jesus further illustrated the reaction of anger and outrage toward his new unconditional message in the parables of the anger of the older brother toward the generously forgiving and merciful father in the Prodigal story (Luke 15). Also, the anger of the all-day vineyard workers toward the generosity of the vineyard owner (Matthew 20). In such short stories he was illustrating that he understood the anger of many faithful Jews, and others, toward the scandalously unconditional nature of God.

Wrapping up here as I do not want to overly beat this drum- Jesus’ protest against the sacrifice industry was also a protest against the primitive view of justice that sacrifice was based on, and a protest against the primitive mythology of a God that demanded payment of all debts, punishment of all wrongs. There was no free or unconditional love in those primitive views of divine justice. It was all “eye for eye” retaliatory justice.

That is why in Luke 6:27-36, Jesus details what his new version of love means in practice and concludes that if we do such things then we will be just like God, “Be unconditionally merciful just like your Father is unconditionally merciful.” Show this kind of behavior and you will be showing the true character of God and the nature of authentic humanity.

Further to this list of core bad ideas– Add (7) the tendency of many to deform the “hero’s quest”, to believe there is a divine demand to heroically engage a righteous battle against evil enemies that must be purged, even exterminated as irredeemably evil, as they are too corrupted, defiled, and existentially threatening to life to allow them to continue living.

This derives from the Zoroastrian cosmic dualism myth (i.e. a Good God warring eternally against an Evil Force/Satan). Based on this cosmic dualism myth, early people believed that there was the follow-up divine demand to join the true religion of the true and good God and to fight the false religion of the false Spirit. The Zoroastrian fallacy has fueled endless tribal enmity and conflict among people across history who frame their conflicts with their opponents in such irredeemably oppositional terms.

This may be one of the most dangerously delusional elements in this list of bad ideas. Especially when people convince themselves that God is on their side, that they are acting on behalf of God, they are God’s chosen people, special and favored by God above all others. Who said that the worst and most dangerous people in society are those who believe that they know what is best for all others? That belief is scaled up, intensified to the highest reach, by adding divinity to the equation to validate people’s sense of being more special than all others, thereby affirming their impulse to domination and busybody meddling in and controlling other’s lives, validated in doing so because they believe they are favored and chosen by God to “do the will of God” and tell others what that will is.

And then, talking about highest reaches of extremism, we further deform the hero’s quest when we frame differing others, the disagreeing “enemies”, as especially hated and despised by God, demonized as the “children of Satan”, and so beyond the pale as to be deserving of eternal hellfire. Quite naturally, that type of thinking leads to similar behaving- i.e. “Let’s help them on their way to their true destination”. Let’s help God send them along to hell by engaging crusades of extermination here on earth.

Tribalism that denies the oneness of human family:

The element of framing enemies as “demonic” intensifies the sense of obligation to exterminate such enemies who are viewed as more existentially dangerous than normal infidels and unbelievers. The view of enemies as some version of especially evil beings informs, for example, the Islamic hatred of the Jews as not just infidels but “demonic/satanic” infidels, more dangerous than all others and therefore deserving more intense hatred and zealous crusades to exterminate.

And if we frame our enemies as so irredeemably terrible because we believe that they threaten all life with what we claim as “existential destruction”, well, then it is an even more a righteous obligation for us to move into the phase of “exterminate them or be exterminated” (the final phase of apocalyptic crusades where desperate heroes must engage “extreme measures” to save their world from existential threats).

Add here the related elements of the divine demand to purge defiling things from life that anger a deity obsessed with perfection and absolute purity.

The above tribalism, fueled by Zoroaster’s fallacy of cosmic dualism, is a denial of the fundamental truth of human oneness, whether affirmed by common human origins with the East African “Mitochondrial Eve”, or based on the ultimate Oneness that is affirmed by the oneness at the most fundamental level of reality as in “quantum entanglement”. Or further affirmed by the ultimate oneness that is stated in NDE accounts of fundamental human oneness with deity.

More on the deforming of the hero’s quest with Zoroastrian tribal dualism, with justice as punitive destruction of irredeemable enemies, and with the fallacy of retaliatory deity that affirms tribalism and vengeful justice:

Heroes (suffering under the burden of the “messiah complex, saviors of the world”), when engaging their righteous battles against evil, further intensify the nature of their struggle with the demand for “instantaneous purging of evil” and “coercive purification”. Once again, the demand for urgency and immediacy is based on the belief that the threat from the enemy is so existentially “immanent” (i.e. the “always soon-coming apocalypse”) that there is no time for the normal gradualism of democratic processes.

The urgency of the immediately looming “end-of-days” demands immediate desperate measures and legitimizes revolutionary violence against threatening enemies in order to “save the world”. See Arthur Mendel on the demand of impatient revolutionaries for “instantaneous purification” versus the gradualism of democracy, in his “Vision and Violence”. Note how repeatedly across past decades the climate alarmism prophets have claimed that evil consumers of fossil fuels were bringing on the end of life, and that the end was only a decade, or few years, up ahead.

Contrary to panic-mongering over immanence, the end of days has been endlessly passed due to the 100% failure rate of apocalyptic prophets.

Then a final theme on this list: (8) The false carrot-stick hope stirred by the promise of fulfilled salvation in the restoration of a paradisal communalism/collectivism (Acts 2-4). Or salvation in a new utopia of a millennial kingdom (i.e. Nazism, Christianity versions). The same salvation is promised in the environmental vision of a return to the falsely imagined “strong, pure” existence of hunter-gatherers more connected to nature (Arthur Herman in “The Idea of Decline”, also “Hitler’s Millennial Reich” by David Redles).

Conclusion:

These psycho-pathological themes have been fiercely defended and maintained across history in our great religious traditions and are now embraced in modern era “secular ideological” belief systems and even promoted by “scientism”. The themes above distort entirely the “true state of life” in the world, they distort the actual long-term trajectory of life. They also distort the true nature of humanity, and consequently produce emotions, motivations, and policy responses that irrationally destroy life to save some imaginary lost world.

Julian Simon countered the “madness of crowds” thinking produced by the above themes with a detailed presentation of evidence on the true state of life, the actual improving trajectory of life over the long-term. The improving trajectory of life and civilization is fueled by essential human goodness, compassion, and creativity.

The above list is the complex of the worst of bad ideas that the ancients created, which they then affirmed with a tribal, dominating, destroying God as the cohering center of the complex, rendering the complex as the “untouchable sacred”, protected from challenge and dissent with threats of “blasphemy, heresy, evil unbelief, and hellfire”.

The above ideas were long ago embedded as primary “archetypes” of the collective human subconscious from where they continue to influence new generations to embrace and live by the same core themes, to create ever new variant narratives/worldviews framed with the same fundamental ideas and beliefs, both religious and secular/ideological. Hence, we get ongoing crusades of “salvation through destruction” ruining our societies.

(End of ‘bad ideas’ complex)

Added notes:

Prompt for AI:

Please list Romans and other New Testament statements on God who is angry with fallen humans for the offense of ruining his originally perfect creation.

Gemini response:

AI Overview

The New Testament presents a comprehensive view of God’s wrath against human sin and the corruption of creation, most systematically laid out by the Apostle Paul in his Letter to the Romans. Rather than portraying an arbitrary rage, the New Testament describes God’s anger as a holy, righteous opposition to the fracturing of a world He designed to be perfect.

Here is how Romans and other New Testament texts outline this concept:

1. The Core Statement in Romans

In the Book of Romans, Paul explains that humanity’s rebellion triggered both a fracture in human nature and a curse upon the physical world.

• Romans 1:18–20 (The Revelation of Wrath): Paul states that “the wrath of God is being revealed from heaven against all the godlessness and wickedness of people.” He argues that humans are without excuse because God’s perfect creation clearly reveals His eternal power and divine nature, yet humanity chose to worship the creation rather than the Creator.

• Romans 3:23 & 5:12 (The Fall): Paul establishes that “all have sinned and fall short of the glory of God.” He traces this back to the beginning, explaining that sin entered the world through one man (Adam), and death through sin, ruining the original design.

• Romans 8:19–22 (The Groaning Creation): Paul directly links human failure to the ruin of the physical universe. He notes that “the creation was subjected to frustration” and is currently in “bondage to decay.” The cosmos itself “groans” as if in childbirth, waiting for the final redemption.

2. Other New Testament Confirmations

Beyond Romans, several other writers emphasize God’s holy anger regarding the corruption of humanity and the earth, alongside the promise of ultimate restoration.

• Ephesians 2:1–3 (Children of Wrath): Paul reminds the church in Ephesus that before following Christ, humans were “by nature deserving of wrath” due to their transgressions and active participation in the corruption of the world.

• Colossians 1:21 (Alienation): This passage notes that humans became “alienated from God and were enemies in [their] minds because of [their] evil behavior,” actively working against His good design.

• John 3:36 (The Abiding Wrath): In John’s Gospel, Jesus’ ministry highlights the stakes of this division: “Whoever believes in the Son has eternal life, but whoever rejects the Son will not see life, for God’s wrath remains on them.”

• Revelation 11:18 (Destroying the Destroyers): In the final book of the New Testament, God’s wrath reaches its climax. The text explicitly states that the time has come for “destroying those who destroy the earth,” showing His ultimate judgment on those who ruin His creation.

3. The Theological Framework

To understand these passages, theologians generally look at three core concepts:

• Holy Justice: God’s anger is not a human temper tantrum; it is the necessary reaction of a perfectly holy being against evil, injustice, and the vandalism of His good work.

• The Cosmic Scope: Sin did not just damage human hearts; it structurally damaged the cosmos, introducing decay, disaster, and death into an originally “very good” creation (Genesis 1:31).

• The Solution: The New Testament never leaves the story at God’s anger. The core of the gospel message is that Jesus absorbed this wrath on the cross (propitiation) to reconcile fallen humans and eventually renew the entire universe (Revelation 21:5).

This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.